News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by tokenadult on Friday February 08, 2013 @08:28PM (#5191120)
Very worth reading if you want to know what it's like to drive a Tesla Model S on an actual road trip. The New York Times reporter John M. Broder finds out that the gauge in the Model S to estimate remaining mileage before the next charge is badly confused by temperatures below the usual temperatures in California.

I remember back when I used to have a travel-intensive job that I was flying into airports all over the United States and getting into unfamiliar models of cars rented on the corporate account. That was sometimes no fun at all. But all of those cars fit everyone's familiar mental model of displaying fuel remaining. The Tesla Model S, by contrast, reports miles still able to drive in a dynamic model that can rapidly get out of touch with reality. And of course it takes a good bit longer to fully recharge a Tesla, even with high-speed recharging, than to pump gasoline into any other kind of car. This will take some major getting used to for most drivers.

Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by jfb on Friday February 08, 2013 @08:39PM (#5191147)
Of course an EV is going to have trouble in cold weather -- it's just physics. It's just surprising to me that so obvious a situation didn't come up in testing the software. As a resident of Toronto who was interested in the Model S, it's a bit eye-opening.
Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by purplelobster on Friday February 08, 2013 @08:46PM (#5191158)
For sure. The lack of charging stations will eventually be solved, but longer charging times and unreliable readings might be with us forever. Hopefully the cost offset for fuel will make it worth it.
Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by jzwinck on Friday February 08, 2013 @11:17PM (#5191634)
Regarding unreliable readings of remaining charge, I'm of two minds. Consider digital cameras, which use a similar battery chemistry. For more than a decade, Sony has for some reason been basically the only manufacturer whose cameras produce a fairly specific and reliable indication of time remaining. Maybe it's a patent thing, but my Sony prosumer camera from 2002 had a better indicator than pretty much anything not from Sony I've seen since.
Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by andrewmccall on Saturday February 09, 2013 @06:11AM (#5192314)
I'm not saying the tesla couldn't be better or that they couldn't learn something from Sony. But part of the author's complain was that he had one reading in the evening and when the temperature dropped overnight his reading the next morning was drastically lower.

Also a while a digital camera does get to spend some time outdoors it spends most of it's life in fairly people comfortable environment.

Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by JamisonM on Saturday February 09, 2013 @12:11AM (#5191778)
There is no reason for unreliable reading to be with us forever, accounting for temperature and driving-style in an estimation system is non-trivial but far from impossible. It is the sort of problem that will be incrementally solved as the technology matures, Telsa themselves will learn from their more northerly deployments.
Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by bwhite on Friday February 08, 2013 @10:20PM (#5191486)
Gas stations are incredibly common. Public EV charging stations will never be as common unless a different business model is adopted.

If EVs become common, people will have home charging stations. Demand for non-at-home charging stations will come from (1) folks who drive a lot and need to charge intraday (and who cannot charge at work) and (2) road trippers. The sum of both of these categories is fairly small and less demand means less supply. So if you do fit into one of those two categories, you will need to plan your driving carefully instead of figuring that you'll be able to pick up some gas when you need it. This can be overcome by arranging for the proliferation of public EV charging stations even absent the demand. Perhaps the manufacturer or municipalities will subsidize it.

Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by glenra on Friday February 08, 2013 @11:02PM (#5191595)
Making people sit and wait for an hour whenever they need to recharge is just plain nuts. It makes the "road tripper" use case untenable. The right way to handle this for road trippers is to swap the battery packs or swap their contents. Don't make the driver wait while his battery is recharged - swap in a full pack and send him on his way. Charge the battery that was left behind slowly and at leisure, then give it to the next driver who pulls in needing a charge.

I don't care how many charging stations there are - adding multiple hours of charging time to a short trip like that is just not going to work.

Although there's one other conceivable option for a technical solution - if you could add charging circuitry to the freeway and recharge while driving, that would be a game-changer.

Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by rm999 on Friday February 08, 2013 @11:17PM (#5191635)
There's a company that's been working on swappable car batteries for some time now:

http://www.betterplace.com/

I agree with you that this is the only realistic mainstream future of electric vehicles as long as batteries remain in their current low-density state.

Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by JamisonM on Saturday February 09, 2013 @12:08AM (#5191769)
If swapping is the answer then in that case you need a non-ownership model for batteries. I am not going to swap out a brand-new battery for a 2 year old one and then be stuck with that one for the foreseeable future on my regular local car use.
Re:Stalled Out on Tesla’s Electric Highway by cshesse on Friday February 08, 2013 @11:46PM (#5191709)
I think what will happen is that people will all own EVs and then rent gas cars for long distance trips until there is some huge breakthrough in battery capacity or charging times.