Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by M8R-fhlcjm on Friday February 08, 2013 @05:19PM
(#5190459)
That's assuming the article is right, but a look around the world shows the opposite - generally speaking the stronger the patent rights, the stronger the innovation. Weak IP African countries vs strong IP in American, European, Japan, Korea.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by glesica on Friday February 08, 2013 @05:41PM
(#5190557)
Oh come on, you can't seriously be using Africa as an example here. Most African countries lack basic infrastructure and many haven't had a peaceful decade in the last 50 years. IP is a type of law, so countries with weak rule of law probably have weak IP. But I think there is a solid case to be made that the other rule of law issues swamp IP in terms of suppressing innovation.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by M8R-fhlcjm on Friday February 08, 2013 @05:56PM
(#5190630)
not so long ago (few hundred years) the new world (America) was behind African infrastructure and yet pulled itself up.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by mullingitover on Friday February 08, 2013 @06:21PM
(#5190731)
One common sense argument is that as industry developed and competition increased, the dominant players were able to perform regulatory capture to ensure that they could rule the market through easily-gamed IP laws.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by M8R-fhlcjm on Friday February 08, 2013 @07:51PM
(#5191026)
Except advancement of western civilization was much more due to technological innovations than 'gaming IP laws'.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by mullingitover on Friday February 08, 2013 @05:45PM
(#5190581)
Exactly, this correlation definitely proves that strong IP rights are the reason for the innovation. It's rock solid, just like this chart[1] that reveals the true cause of global warming.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by M8R-fhlcjm on Friday February 08, 2013 @06:14PM
(#5190705)
About as hard to prove direct correlation as for you to prove the opposite. However, use common sense. The data is overwhelmingly in my favor.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by e40 on Friday February 08, 2013 @05:40PM
(#5190553)
What came first, though, strong IP or innovation? I could see strong IP laws growing out of existing innovation.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by rednukleus on Friday February 08, 2013 @05:41PM
(#5190561)
Call me crazy, but I don't think a lack of strict patent law is the only thing holding African countries back.
Re:Patents and Innovation: Evidence from Economic History [...
by M8R-fhlcjm on Friday February 08, 2013 @06:15PM
(#5190711)
IP laws not only thing holding them back. But it ain't helping either. No incentive to spend resources (be they $money, or time inventing).
The article suggests that the available evidence does not support this conclusion. It seems that in historical technology fairs, countries with a weak or no patent system in place performed as well as other countries, both in terms of numbers of inventions they presented, and awards they received.
The article also describes some instances where patents clearly inhibited innovation - for example in the US in 1916, aircraft production halted due to patent disputes between Wright and Curtiss.