News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

M8R-fhlcjm

Re:Patent troll goes after popular podcasters on Thursday February 28, 2013 @01:44PM (#5300140)
did you not see the "compilation file" elements?
Re:Patent troll goes after popular podcasters on Thursday February 28, 2013 @01:43PM (#5300131)
Just start with the Claims and go from there. You must literally infringe every single word (that's why patent Claims seem so awkwardly worded).

Simply not do ANY ONE OF THE following:

> "series of episodes"

So a single episode and you may avoid infringement

> "performing, from time to time, one of a sequence of update operations"

So eliminate periodic operations, or sequence of updates and you may avoid infringement

> "each of said update operations comprising: downloading via the Internet the current version of a compilation file identified by a predetermined known URL"

So either don't identify using known URL (admittedly not likely but worth mentioning), avoid what they defined "compilation file" to be, or even avoid "predetermined" and you may avoid infringement

> ", and storing attribute data contained in said current version of said compilation file in said digital memory, said attribute data describing one or more episodes in a series of episodes"

Now it starts sounding like "compilation file" is more than just a mp3 file. So the first support I find (CTRL-F is your friend) related is:

> "The download compilation file 145, though represented as a single file in FIG. 1, preferably takes the form of one or more subscriber and session specific files which contain the identification of separately stored sharable files. By way of example, the recommended order and the identification of the program files making up an individual playback session are stored in a session schedule file (to be described in detail in connection with FIG. 5) which contains program identifiers of the program segments to be played during an upcoming session. The player 103 downloads the session schedule file and then issues download requests for those identified program segment files which are not already available in the player's local storage unit 107."

Add to this, FIG. 5 and FIG. 6, and it looks like compilation file includes one or more things like indexes, transcripts, condensed content, topic description, paragraphs, etc... So avoiding this "compilation file" is probably their best bet - just serve straight up mp3 files and you may avoid infringement but compile mp3 into these "compilation files" and you're infringing.

What troubles me is that I'm not an expert but yet have found plenty of options for Carolla/etc to avoid this (and relatively cheaply). So who's the patent lawyer giving Carolla advice to fight this? Probably the EFF as part of their anti-patent propaganda.

Given your example of cell phones, there's a lot more costs to bringing a new type of cell phone to market than the ~$50k on patent searches.

Since we're talking about driving innovation, someone who genuinely advances the technology is able to gain some protection on their investment in R&D by applying for (and hopefully obtaining) a patent(s).

If all you're doing is bringing another same-old cell phone to market then the question is what benefits are you bringing - or rather, does society benefit more from your same-cellphone than the someone who is innovating and introducing something new and novel.

Except advancement of western civilization was much more due to technological innovations than 'gaming IP laws'.
1) Where is the evidence of the opposite? The data is overwhelmingly. 2) U.S. is certainly in the top tier of strongest patent laws.
IP laws not only thing holding them back. But it ain't helping either. No incentive to spend resources (be they $money, or time inventing).
About as hard to prove direct correlation as for you to prove the opposite. However, use common sense. The data is overwhelmingly in my favor.
That's a cop-out given the abundance of search tools, regexp, CTRL-F, etc...
not so long ago (few hundred years) the new world (America) was behind African infrastructure and yet pulled itself up.
from the article:

    "In countries without patent laws, inventors depend entirely on secrecy, lead time, and other alternatives to patents in protecting their intellectual property."

This has been shown time and again, remove patents and you remove the incentive to disclose.
That's assuming the article is right, but a look around the world shows the opposite - generally speaking the stronger the patent rights, the stronger the innovation. Weak IP African countries vs strong IP in American, European, Japan, Korea.
Patents provide the incentive to invest in R&D by providing a form of guarantee on their investments.

Generally speaking, the countries with the strongest patent rights produce many of the innovative companies.

Re:Top 50 U.S. Patent Assignees of 2012 on Thursday January 10, 2013 @08:14PM (#5040798)
Not really, 1) Google wants into mobile more than Apple wants into search or ads, and 2) Apple has more mobile patents.
Re:Top 50 U.S. Patent Assignees of 2012 on Thursday January 10, 2013 @07:05PM (#5040554)
events from the past couple of years have changed all of that. These numbers support that.
Re:Top 50 U.S. Patent Assignees of 2012 on Thursday January 10, 2013 @06:33PM (#5040423)
Google more than Apple is a sign of things to come.
Re:Apple's pinch-to-zoom patent invalidated by USPTO on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @09:47PM (#4946051)
sure, and now China is repeating history.
Re:Apple's pinch-to-zoom patent invalidated by USPTO on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @09:46PM (#4946046)
China's idea of stepping up IP enforcement is case-by-case. Read: however it benefits the Chinese company vs the foreigner.

Also useful to note their increase is mainly quantity. Superficial.

Re:Apple's pinch-to-zoom patent invalidated by USPTO on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @09:43PM (#4946038)
I see, "troll" because I don't conform to your opinion. What is this, slashdot?

> Try asking it to prove that the economic prosperity is caused by the patent system rather than merely correlated.

About as provable as the opposite.

Re:Apple's pinch-to-zoom patent invalidated by USPTO on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @09:39PM (#4946028)
China's relative recent rise is predicated on copying - not innovating. As patent rights are weakened, investors are increasingly reluctant to invest in $costly American R&D that can just be copied at a fraction of the R&D $cost.

Pick your poison: compete with China on lowest cost vs. high end jobs innovating. Except the later affords a more affluent lifestyle while the former require suicide nets in their buildings: http://i.imgur.com/JwBDR.jpg

Re:Apple's pinch-to-zoom patent invalidated by USPTO on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @06:52PM (#4945523)
economies of countries with patent rights exceed economies without patents.

And at the top is the U.S.A. with strongest patent rights.

biggest != technical innovation

Quake 1 had better graphics and editors eons ago

Re:Apple's pinch-to-zoom patent invalidated by USPTO on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @06:46PM (#4945496)
which element do you want me to support?: 1) R&D costs money 2) investors look for return on their investment 3) corporations continuously look to reduce costs

Perhaps it is you who is continuing the echo chamber.

Re:Things Bosses Wish They Could Tell Employees on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @06:36PM (#4945461)
The article missed:

I found an eager soul in a foreign country with similar skills for less than half your salary.

Re:Apple's pinch-to-zoom patent invalidated by USPTO on Wednesday December 19, 2012 @06:31PM (#4945448)
R&D costs money, and lots of it.

So in the end, patents provided the incentive to innovate and $spend on R&D in America, and now free for all to copy. Without patents, smart investors will start to look at where they can most cheaply copy American innovations.

what exactly have Cuban or Minecraft innovated?
Provide incentives to publish innovations instead of trade secrets. Allow others to stand on shoulders of giants.
You won't be able to create an exception for software not to be patentable. It's over, get used to it and move on.