News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by user24 on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @09:44AM (#5170834)
> For those not familiar with functional analysis, it is basically a generalization of basic linear algebra fact that, in complex finite-dimensional vector spaces, every matrix (or to be more precise, every linear operator) has at least one eigenvector.

Oh, thanks for the clarification.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by ot on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:42AM (#5171193)
I sense some sarcasm :) Luckily these things have nice geometrical interpretations, let me try to clarify this better, hoping that I can stimulate some curiosity on the subject.

Imagine a linear transformation in the 3-dimensional space; that means that rotations, "flips", and scalings are allowed. For example take a rotation: points that are in the axis of rotation remain on that line. Likewise, think of the plane orthogonal to the axis of rotation, then points that are on that plane rotate, but they stay on that plane. The axis of rotation and its orthogonal plane are both invariant subspaces.

In a 3-dimensional space, and in general in every odd-dimensional space, every linear transformation has an invariant subspace. This is not true for even-dimensional spaces, such as the 2d plane: a 45-degree rotation for example has no invariant subspace (except for {0} and the whole space, of course). However, if you allow the coordinates to be complex numbers, instead of real, then there always is an invariant subspace, although it is harder to visualize.

To express this in linear algebra terms, every complex matrix has an eigenvector. This is a fundamental fact that has applications pretty much everywhere in mathematics.

The Invariant Subspace problem generalizes this statement to spaces that are infinite-dimensional. Infinite-dimensional spaces are infinitely messy, so we restrict our attention to spaces that have some additional structure; for example Hilbert spaces, those addressed in the paper, are those where a formula very similar to the Pythagorean theorem is true.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by user24 on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:32AM (#5171509)
Thanks for your detailed reply.

It's a lot to digest. As I explained in another reply, my mathematics is very poor indeed.

> Likewise, think of the plane orthogonal to the axis of rotation, then points that are on that plane rotate, but they stay on that plane.

Why only the orthogonal plane, I don't see how any set of points behaves differently to any other. For example the stars could be said to rotate around the earth (I know, but pretend). They don't move in relation one another though. They only change relative to the earth. I think I'm grossly misunderstanding. Does 'rotation' have a special meaning in this context?

> 45-degree rotation for example has no invariant subspace

because you can rotate points on a line 45 degrees and the only one that stays the same is 0,0, which you call {0}?

So.. someone tried to prove that for n dimenional (odd?) spaces with n<=infinity, there is always some subspace which doesn't differ when you apply complex transformations to it? But was wrong.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by nickpinkston on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @12:43PM (#5171980)
To get better intuition without a math degree I'd recommend: Concepts of Modern Mathematics which only requires elementary algebra, but will give you great intro treatments of everything from groups to number theory.

http://www.amazon.com/Concepts-Modern-Mathematics-Ian-Stewar...

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by neutronicus on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @01:12PM (#5172156)
The important part about the orthogonal plane is that when you rotate it, all pairs of points that were in the orthogonal plane before are still in the orthogonal plane.

Same thing is true of the axis of rotation.

All other pairs of points will be in a different plane than they were before the rotation.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by btilly on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:52AM (#5171252)
I know all of the math you discussed, so for me what you said makes perfect sense.

I very much doubt that it makes much sense to anyone who does not know linear algebra reasonably well.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by tsewlliw on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:54AM (#5171268)
I'm curious, but I think I'd need a practical example
Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by ColinWright on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:30AM (#5171113)
A linear transformation is one that leaves the origin where it is, and maps straight lines to straight lines. It is a theorem that every complex linear transformation has some line that gets mapped to itself - an eigen-line.

Does that help?

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by user24 on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:24AM (#5171455)
I think so, thanks. My maths skills are generally very poor indeed, but OTOH I have an MSc in Computer Science* so I should understand some of this sort of stuff.

I always feel like I'm missing detail, eg:

> every complex linear transformation

Is that "complex" important?

> line that gets mapped to itself

So a trivial example might be a 360 degree rotation? Or am I just way misunderstanding this stuff?

* and I do mean real CS, not software engineering.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by ColinWright on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @03:25AM (#5175458)

  >> line that gets mapped to itself
  > So a trivial example might be a
  > 360 degree rotation?
That's a very trivial example, and therefore good. Less trivial examples are a sheer, an expansion, or a rotation in 3D space.

A rotation in 2D space apparently only leaves the origin fixed, and that's where we need complex numbers. To find a fixed line in that case we need to find roots of a quadratic with negative discriminant, hence needing sqrts of negative numbers.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by btilly on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:27AM (#5171473)
Complex is important. The eigenvectors for rotation by 90 degrees require complex numbers.
Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by user24 on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:34AM (#5171518)
I have no idea what a complex number is. I wish I'd paid more attention in school.
Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by btilly on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:40AM (#5171551)
Complex numbers are just numbers that can have an imaginary component. Like 5+3i. All real numbers are complex (they just have an imaginary component of 0), but the converse is obviously not true.
Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by user24 on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:56AM (#5171670)
I've bookmarked the wiki page on this stuff for later. Otherwise my next question would just be "what's an imaginary component?"

I don't think my tutors at Oxford really understood exactly what I meant by "I can't do all this maths". Basic gaps in my knowledge. Still passed though, fuck yeah! :D

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by lmkg on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @12:22PM (#5171847)
"Imaginary" numbers are the square roots of negative numbers.

Because (-1)^2 = 1^2 = 1, these numbers don't exist on the regular ("real") number line. Instead we wave our hands and posit the existence of the magical number i, the imaginary unit, that has the property i^2 = -1. Through simple algebra, this unit is enough to give us square roots for all the imaginary numbers. For example, (3i)^2 = -9.

Imaginary numbers are "independent" of the real numbers, which means that the sum of 5 and 3i is simply 5+3i. That expression cannot be simplified further. Such sums are called "complex" numbers. The complex numbers can be imagined as a plane, with the horizontal axis consisting of the pure reals, and the vertical axis consisting of the pure imaginaries.

Complex numbers support all the regular arithmetic operations. You can figure them out yourself, so long as you remember i^2 = -1. In the complex plane, addition looks like vector addition, and multiplying by an imaginary number is a rotation.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by dbaupp on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:06AM (#5170953)
It helped me, and they (the analogy and OP) seem like something very hard to explain briefly to someone not versed in linear algebra.

Edit: clearly it's possible though, as the other replies attest to.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by btilly on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @01:07PM (#5172114)
It is possible to briefly explain enough to people to fool them into thinking that they have a sense of the discussion. However this is a form of intellectual entertainment, and not actual explanation.

Several times I began trying to write an actual explanation of what a vector space is, a linear function, a subspace, a Banach space, a Hilbert space, and what the actual conjecture is. I got bogged down every time.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by fghh45sdfhr3 on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @10:42AM (#5171190)
I don't like the snarky tone of your comment. However, I do want to encourage learning. So if you are genuinely curious, try asking for a better explanation here: http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/
Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by user24 on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:21AM (#5171435)
I don't like the patronising tone of your comment. However, I do want to encourage discourse. So if you're genuinely interested in helping people understand, try rephrasing your comment to not imply that five year olds should be conversant with linear algebra.

PS: Now that's a snarky tone. My original comment was merely lightly sarcastic.

Re:Mistake found in invariant subspace proof by misnome on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @11:20AM (#5171425)
I don't know many six year olds that would have no issue with that description. ot's reply clears things up nicely, but again, I doubt to the simplicity which you are suggesting he needs.

Besides, I read sarcasm, not snark.