News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Most of you steal your software" by alan_cx on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:46AM (#5163294)
... and as a result poor Bill has lived in total poverty, only to die of scurvy in a slum. His business died with out trace and he never been heard of since. A tragic story. Yes, bad hobbyists.

Point being, despite all the piracy, there is still some money to be made. The complaint is that such folk are not making enough money. See, Bill should be twice or 3 times as rich. Man, he's really losing out.

Of course then we have to deal with the age old assumption that every person with a pirated copy would have paid for it. Which is, er, optimistic, at best. IMHO, the loss is negligible. All they the copyright owner gets in reality is the satisfaction that not so many people use their product, but those who do pay.

I'm not that happy at hitting Bill with this as he is one of the filthy rich people who actually uses his accumulated wealth for good causes. Which is ideal really.

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by zero_intp on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:01AM (#5163472)
The great philanthropic era was a result of the robber barons. The idea that we might enter a new era of such figures is only a sign of the grossly disproportionate wealth scales that damage our societies.

It is a despotic idea that society must endure the deprivations of these individuals or corporation only to be rewarded with narrow visions of a better future world through the myopic eyes of the DuPont's, Gates', or Carnegie's of the world. These "great" men robbed, captured, or monopolized vast tracts of our communal resources in their acquisition of said wealth (edit: I accidentally an 'r')

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by carlob on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:36AM (#5163760)
Yes! Next time you visit the Frick collection in New York City (you really should) think about the bloody repression of the Homestead strike [0].

I really think that the likes of Gates, Frick, Carnegie, Rockefeller or the more recent Jim Simons. Should have been taxed at a much much steeper rate, just like Buffett proposed [1], instead of waiting for their kindness of heart.

By replacing philanthropy with taxation we get the democratic process to choose what is the best way to spend this money, instead of their however enlightened agenda.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homestead_Steel_Strike

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buffett_Rule

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by jacoblyles on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:59AM (#5165235)
So we should tax away Thiel's money so instead of Space X we get... more ethanol subsidies? Or we should tax away Cameron's money so instead of asteroid mining we get higher pensions for government union workers?

What kind of world do you live in that allows you this kind of democratic idealism?

As our population gets older, the priorities of our democracies will reflect that. More and more government spending will go towards risk-averse projects - mostly medical subsidy. The only truly radical innovation will come from eccentric billionaires.

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by carlob on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @09:27AM (#5170746)
Well first of all Thiel's venture is a company not philantropy…

But hell yeah, more pensions, universal healthcare, maybe more spending on education (talking about public school not 40k$/year colleges) are definitely a better way to spend money than radical innovation of eccentric billionaires.

Moreover what we're talking about here is not turning billionaires into mere millionaires, but taxing people who can afford to donate 95% of their fortune 30% instead of 15%. That still leaves ample room for eccentric innovation. Yours is a false dichotomy.

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by jacoblyles on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @06:22PM (#5173988)
The United States is one of the biggest spenders in the world on K-12 education. How much more money do you want to spend on a broken system?

The unions get much better pensions than the rest of us. And their political machines own the state capitals. How much higher should they go?

The United States spends far more money per person on health care than other countries. How much more do you want to spend?

This year, the top capital gains tax rate in California went up 52%. That's a substantial bite on innovation to ensure public workers get gold-plated defined-benefit pensions.

America's government may be inefficient, but it is not stingy.

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by carlob on Tuesday February 05, 2013 @07:33PM (#5174247)
>The United States is one of the biggest spenders in the world on K-12 education. How much more money do you want to spend on a broken system?

Certainly spending less won't fix it.

>The unions get much better pensions than the rest of us. And their political machines own the state capitals. How much higher should they go?

Extend those rights to non unionized workers.

>The United States spends far more money per person on health care than other countries. How much more do you want to spend?

I want to spend less by having universal public healthcare.

>This year, the top capital gains tax rate in California went up 52%. That's a substantial bite on innovation to ensure public workers get gold-plated defined-benefit pensions.

Capital tax gains mostly affect more affluent households. I'm willing to bet that even with this rate, taxation is regressive in the US.

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by tokenadult on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:04AM (#5164070)
Part of this subthread discusses how Bill Gates started out in life and how much he has prospered since he wrote the open letter. Just on that point, it might be of interest to check an online post "Why Bill Gates is Richer than You" (more than a decade old, before Gates got involved in philanthropy full time) about how he made his money.

http://philip.greenspun.com/humor/bill-gates

Note that I have not fact-checked this at all, so if anyone has any factual corrections or updates (which could come from one of the published biographical writings about Gates), I would be glad to hear them.

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by edraferi on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:16AM (#5164880)
Interesting link, with some prescience:

"What most users want, though, is a cheap simple device that lets them collaborate with others... Thus the market for computing may in the end boil down to simple stuff to be used by consumers and reliable stuff to be operated by professional IT staff. Windows is way too complex for most consumers and difficult to justify on the server side when you can run Linux for free."

e.g. "someday we'll just build the cloud on LAMP"

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by ghjm on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:21AM (#5163375)
But he wasn't, or anything close to it, when he wrote this letter.
Re:"Most of you steal your software" by rbanffy on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:11AM (#5163691)
He wasn't anything close to poverty either.
Re:"Most of you steal your software" by OGinparadise on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:05AM (#5164080)
He wasn't anything close to poverty either.

OK, if you aren't poor, give me $10K then. According to me, you have enough!

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by rbanffy on Monday February 04, 2013 @11:02AM (#5164760)
That, in 1955 dollars, would be about 1% of the trust fund one of his grandparents established for him.

Still, I think he would resist your offer. What would you do with US$10K?

Re:"Most of you steal your software" by wglb on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:54PM (#5167050)
He came from a quite well off family. And used that to his advantage at the beginning of his business career.
Re:"Most of you steal your software" by rmrfrmrf on Monday February 04, 2013 @08:47AM (#5164020)
I find your disdain for the wealthy disturbing.