News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by fauigerzigerk on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:46AM (#5163137)
And most apps require permissions that have very little to do with the purpose of the app. Here's what the BBC news reader for Android wants:

THIS APPLICATION HAS ACCESS TO THE FOLLOWING:

HARDWARE CONTROLS

CHANGE YOUR AUDIO SETTINGS

Allows the app to modify global audio settings such as volume and which speaker is used for output.

NETWORK COMMUNICATION

FULL NETWORK ACCESS

Allows the app to create network sockets and use custom network protocols. The browser and other applications provide means to send data to the internet, so this permission is not required to send data to the internet.

PHONE CALLS

READ PHONE STATUS AND IDENTITY

Allows the app to access the phone features of the device. This permission allows the app to determine the phone number and device IDs, whether a call is active, and the remote number connected by a call.

STORAGE

MODIFY OR DELETE THE CONTENTS OF YOUR USB STORAGE MODIFY OR DELETE THE CONTENTS OF YOUR SD CARD

Allows the app to write to the USB storage. Allows the app to write to the SD card.

SYSTEM TOOLS

PREVENT TABLET FROM SLEEPING PREVENT PHONE FROM SLEEPING

Allows the app to prevent the tablet from going to sleep. Allows the app to prevent the phone from going to sleep.

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by angryasian on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:57AM (#5163161)
All these are sort of explainable, Hardware and Audio is to allow the user to control volume or widgets for feeds and multimedia.

Network access is usually reserved for multimedia

Phone Calls - status - is usually because if you receive a phone call any multimedia knows when to stop

storage - to store things to your sd card or move the app to your sd card

prevent from sleeping - if you're watching a video you don't want the screen to sleep.

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by fauigerzigerk on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:57AM (#5163322)
Right, so in order to duplicate everything the browser already does, they "need" these overly broad permissions. That's exactly the point the OP was making.

I think the real problem is that permissions are either too broad for the purpose of displaying some content, or they are too many for anyone to understand. My conclusion is that such apps simply make no sense.

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by scanr on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:58AM (#5164351)
They may be explainable but do you really want to install an app that _could_ keep track of the numbers you call and then send them back to a central server?

In this case it is the BBC, so its probably only likely that the british government, the metropolitan police or mi 5/6 would be able to convince them to do it but a whole lot of less scrupulous organisations ask for that permission.

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by epochwolf on Monday February 04, 2013 @10:37AM (#5164601)
Looks like android needs to fix it's permissions system.
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by jcomis on Monday February 04, 2013 @03:40PM (#5166958)
I think Android permissions are probably the best at the moment, because they actually exist, are centrally located, and are easy to read. You won't see any certain permission detail longer than a few sentences. They also are shared, so if you have seen one permission for an app to access your contacts, it will be the same in all apps. Apple requires less permissions disclosure and they can be listed in the app store, or on the developers site.

However, ideally I would like to see the current Android permissions segmented further. Right now they act as a catch all to ensure all bases are covered. This is often way beyond what most apps need and actually use, making users second guess what they are installing (at least, they do for me).

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by angryasian on Monday February 04, 2013 @01:44PM (#5166093)
the only difference between ios and android is android tells you the permissions an app requires. All mobile os need their permission systems fixed
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by kamkazemoose on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:05AM (#5163183)
I'm not an expert on Android permissions, but those seem reasonable to me. What permissions do you have a problem with, and what should they replace it with, or do you think is totally unnecessary?
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by tommorris on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:24AM (#5163243)
It would be interesting to know why a news reading application needs full access to my file system.
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by berkut on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:30AM (#5163259)
The BBC news app caches pics and content - that's how when you open it a second time (even if it was shut down) it can show the tiles really quickly without downloading them.
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by tommorris on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:37AM (#5163281)
Okay, and why does that mean it needs access to my complete filesystem rather than just a little namespaced, security-controlled chunk of filesystem allocated by the OS to it?
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by lnanek2 on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:08AM (#5163338)
Historically, on Android, there has been very little space in the data area for each individual app. An app that cached to that would have been unusable on my Nexus One for example, where I constantly had to delete apps whenever I wanted to install a new one, and I had very few - something like 10 or 15.

The best place for the user has been to cache to the SD card, or the internal storage partition setup to look like an SD card. There are even many root required hacks to move app data to there and similar. The storage permission is needed to access the SD card, however.

Even in non-rooted Android things are changing, however. Apps that accept certain limitations, like no reliable background services, can be set to be installed to SD card. The latest versions do away with mounting as an SD card entirely and should help unify the storage, although everyone hates the new MTP protocol being used to access data from the PC when the phone is plugging in now.

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by fauigerzigerk on Monday February 04, 2013 @05:25AM (#5163380)
One issue with these permissions is that I don't have a clue what they mean. Does the list of permissions I posted give that app the right to read all my personal data and upload it to one of their servers? Can it delete all my contacts or pictures? Can it make phone calls on my behalf or record my phone calls and upload the audio file to a server?
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by andrewaylett on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:01AM (#5163470)
I know it's not answering your actual point, but I'll answer your specific questions. No, it can't record audio, or make phone calls on your behalf -- both require specific permissions that aren't listed here. It can't access your contacts at all, either, as that requires a specific permission.

Pictures are stored on the SD card, so the app could read all your pictures, upload them, then delete them. Newer devices have more internal storage, so hopefully applications will gradually move away from using this permission. Apparently, the next version of Android will introduce a new permission for reading the SD card too -- at present, any application may read from the SD card.

"Read[ing] all my personal data" depends on what you count as personal data -- security-sensitive info should not be on the SD card (things like phone number (although the phone state and identity permission gives access to this), contacts, account details), but anything that is on the SD card may be read by any application. That means pictures and music, at least.

I wonder if it might be useful to always list all of the common permissions, to make it easier to see which ones an application doesn't have. I've installed enough Android apps to have a reasonable idea of what's available (and by extension, what any given app can't do) but it's reasonable to assume I'm in a small minority.

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by fauigerzigerk on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:52AM (#5163631)
Thanks for the info. I agree that knowing what an app can't do would be very useful.

And I think there should be a notion of "secure/private/encrypted storage". So when I tell an app to store some item there, I can be absolutely certain that no other app will ever be able to access it, regardless of any permissions.

Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by andrewaylett on Wednesday February 06, 2013 @11:47AM (#5177385)
Every app has its own protected storage space, but that's historically often been quite restricted in size. This is where things like SQLite databases are usually stored. It's also (pretty much by definition) not accessible using a file manager and it's much more difficult to share data from it, so it's not appropriate for music or pictures.
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by Nikker on Monday February 04, 2013 @07:02AM (#5163658)
Why not just do the same thing we have been using for years, /tmp. If the program just needs scratch space why do we deem it proper to allow any app to traverse an entire partition so it can set down a couple of files?
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by joseflavio on Monday February 04, 2013 @04:59AM (#5163324)
That's why you are better off with Android + Opera and change your user agent for Desktop. It is a not perfect solution but works.
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by StavrosK on Monday February 04, 2013 @06:53AM (#5163633)
Plus, Opera mobile is, by far, the snappiest Android browser I've used.
Re:No, I'm not going to download your bullshit app by shurcooL on Monday February 04, 2013 @09:35AM (#5164229)
I use Chrome for iOS's "Request Desktop Site" feature so much. Very useful on my iPad mini (my only mobile device).