Re:Why Amazon Is Special and Apple Is Not
by fspeech on Sunday February 03, 2013 @04:26PM
(#5161233)
I mostly agree with what you are saying. The reason we are having a discussion here is that there are at least two ways to look at the fact that Apple enjoys both mass volume and high margin:
1. Apple has an amazing business.
2. Despite 1 it is not sustainable to have both mass volume and high margin.
I am trying to come up with counter examples of point 2. Coca Cola, McDonald's and Microsoft come to mind, but they share a common characteristic in that these companies control a small but high margin part of their respective value chains. The end products that consumers actually buy (Coke, burgers and PCs) are mass volume and low margin.
I'd agree that mass volume and high margin is hard to pull off, and often proves unstable. I think this is why Apple often doesn't try to address all of a market. They only produce a handful of desktop and laptop models, they have resisted producing a large format phone (though I do expect that to change), etc. They value product consistency over feature and form factor proliferation. They are perfectly happy to occupy the high end of the market, and leave the low end to others.
There's not wishful thinking in any of this. Amazon and Apple are not startups, they are both mature businesses in their prime. They still have a lot of risks and opportunities ahead of them for sure, but Amazon started business I think 17 years ago. Arguably Apple's reconstruction into the company it is today started at around the same time with the NeXT acquisition and the return of Steve Jobs. That's a significant track record on which to evaluate them.