News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacker News Karma Tracker by simias on Sunday February 03, 2013 @02:27PM (#5160747)
slashdot does let you choose the meaning of your "upvote". While its comment system is far from perfect, it does have many good ideas. For some reason, I felt like karma whoring was less of an issue back when I was over there. Maybe because you could only be upvoted 5 times per comment, and you couldn't directly submit stories.
Re:Hacker News Karma Tracker by dfc on Sunday February 03, 2013 @02:53PM (#5160873)
This is the one thing I have always missed about slashdot discussions. I rarely value the "humorous" posts on sites like this. It is not that I do not find the jokes funny, I do, its just that I'd rather increase the SNR even at the cost of a few chuckles. I think the big impediment to widespread adoption is the difficulty in creating an useful interface for tracking "kind of upvote" and then filtering based on type of upvote. I always had my slashdot prefs set up so that I never saw the "+5 funny comments."