News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by mmanfrin on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:20PM (#5152362)
Sorry for my meta-snark, but:

This is an example of bad editing of the title. The original one was much more descriptive and got to the core of what is interesting about this article. The edit has made the title bland and uninformative.

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by manaskarekar on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:08PM (#5152688)
A controversial suggestion:

Mention a small indicator ('*' or '~') below or after a renamed title, clicking on which will show a log of the original title, the name of the admin who made the change and a footnote.

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by petercooper on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:17PM (#5152749)
The original title could also be in a "title" element on the A tag so that hovering over it would show the original. (Not necessarily a better idea but involves no interface changes which the YC folks seem not to like doing.)
Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by cliveholloway on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:10PM (#5152704)
I clicked through after seeing original headline. It made sense. This means nothing to me at all. Aren't editors meant to make things more readable?
Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by incision on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:55PM (#5152582)
I've seen a comment or two about title-editing, but this is the first time I've observed it and I certainly agree.

This is a pointless edit: A useful, descriptive, non-sensational / non-opinionated title replaced with something that is just plain worse.

How did this even get started? Too much bitching / derailing about editorialized titles?

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by teach on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:01PM (#5152628)
"How did this even get started?"

Well, the Hacker News guidelines[1] say:

> Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait.

This rule is frequently violated, because a lot of the times the original title is bad. So submitters that are used to reddit re-title the link, sometimes for worse and sometimes for the better.

But HN is pretty strict about the title rule, so they get edited back to the original pretty quickly.

[1] http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by petercooper on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:19PM (#5152765)
Weird. They've changed the rules. What you quoted seemed very weird to me since I'd sorta internalized the guidelines and it seems they got edited over the past year. See http://web.archive.org/web/20120222184108/http://ycombinator... for what they were a year ago.

You can make up a new title if you want, but if you put gratuitous editorial spin on it, the editors may rewrite it.

It seems that part has been thrown out the window and rewrites are no longer welcome. A shame.

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by teach on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:45PM (#5152964)
It is a shame. As it stands now, the system "punishes" rule followers who leave the original, uninteresting title and thereby get no traction.

But those who rewrite the title to something more obviously relevant get decent views even if the submission is re-titled later.

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by petercooper on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:55PM (#5153418)
That's why I think the removal of the "you can make up a new title [as long as it's not ridiculous]" rule is bizarre. Now you might as well break the rules to get out of /newest and then confuse everyone once it's on FP and edited back ;-)

The sad fact is a lot of people who create great content are really, really bad at titles.

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by incision on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:24PM (#5152784)
Interesting that submitters are actually asked to do a handful of editing work that could probably be automated, but prevented from performing the subjective work of summarizing or restating that a human being is actually suited to.

Seems like a rule worth changing to me.

Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by inovica on Friday February 01, 2013 @01:55PM (#5152588)
Fully agree with you. I saw the article earlier and thought I'd come back to read it and discovered that either its been edited or that this is a second article.
Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by petercooper on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:20PM (#5152768)
It appears the guidelines page got changed in the past year and the "You can make up a new title if you want, but if you put gratuitous editorial spin on it, the editors may rewrite it" clause has been removed :-(
Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by erode on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:05PM (#5152662)
Noticed that and was glad to see I wasn't the only one. Was it done by an admin? If it was, they need to take a cue from reddit admins.
Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by ricardobeat on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:17PM (#5152752)
What was the original title?
Re:Mojang's Monster Profits by Matti on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:21PM (#5152773)