Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by alexhawdon on Thursday January 31, 2013 @04:22PM
(#5147558)
Might be interesting to combine the data with that from fear.com (sorry - police.uk, or whatever the equivalent site is in your country if you have one) to locate places where lower rents intersect with favourable crime-rates.
Another extension might be a third layer that indicates travel times to a destination of your choice.
Finally, demographic information might be useful.
End result: find an affordable place, in a safe neighbourhood populated by people like you. I realise the quality of data available would make this near-impossible. Today.
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by amalcon on Thursday January 31, 2013 @07:30PM
(#5148423)
This particular map can be approximated pretty well by the function 1/(public transit time to Park Street Station). There are a few exceptions, mostly in areas with higher crime rates than the rest of the region.
I don't know why people don't make walking a bigger deal in where they choose to live in the U.S. I love driving, but
A large part of the reason I've remained in New Hampshire is because my town is extremely walkable from my house, with several cafes, good restaurants, and my work all less than 10 minutes away by foot.
(Of course there are other reasons. I "run" a large victorian-era house and rent spare rooms to friends, living for effectively free. On the other hand, I also don't know why more young professionals don't do that, because the money I save is amazing, and the only downside are more chores, or people problems if you live with friends you end up not liking)
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by cmbaus on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:41PM
(#5148868)
Funny I used to live in a large victorian mansion in Epping years ago. I wanted to replicate something like that when I moved to Tahoe, but couldn't afford a property big enough to make it work out.
The guy who wrote Padmapper says this tool puts a pretty heavy load on his server and he
would rather it was run no more than once a month. If you're just looking for some
apartment data, I've put some in apts-2013-01-29, which is for Boston in January 2013.
Please be considerate when running this. It does multiple querries to padmapper, one for each choice in number of bedrooms (0 to 9) times the number of 25$ increments in rent between 100$ and MAX_RENT. Consider tweaking those variables and maybe the 100 lower limit at https://github.com/jeffkaufman/apartment_prices/blob/master/...
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by cbr on Thursday January 31, 2013 @09:50PM
(#5148906)
When I first wrote it I talked to padmapper, and they said that as long as I wasn't going to run it very often it made more sense to keep with the horribly inefficient method in query_padmapper.py than for him to put a bunch of time into making something fancier available. Though a dump of the whole country doesn't sound like it would be that hard and making a US-sized map would be awesome.
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by ericd on Thursday January 31, 2013 @11:37PM
(#5149229)
Yeah, it's a bit more worrying that it's public code, but I imagine that it will be fairly limited, and it seems like people find it useful, so it's probably not a big deal as long as people don't use it too frequently. If there's enough interest, perhaps I should make this heatmap an option on PM itself so that people don't have to all make their own? Would you be OK with my using the code for that?
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by textminer on Friday February 01, 2013 @12:05PM
(#5151906)
About computationally as complex, no? The Manhattan distance would just be the sum of the absolute difference in the two coordinates.
The Manhattan and Euclidean distance on finite spaces both generalize to "l_p norms" (1 and 2, respectively) on an n-dimensional Euclidean space, where ||x||_p = (|x_0|^p + |x_1|^p + ... + |x_n|^p)^(1/p). You can even naturally define it in the limit where p goes to infinity!
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by crazcarl on Thursday January 31, 2013 @06:13PM
(#5148105)
What is the value of an aggregated price per room across all apartment sizes? A 1 room apartment is going to cost more than half of a 2 room apartment, which is going to cost more than one third of a 3 room apartment.
The price per room seems like it would be more useful if it was shown as "price per room for 1bdrm" and able to be switched to 2bdrm or 3bdrm and so on.
Breaking it down by bedroom each map would have fewer points. The most common apartment size is the two bedroom, and there are only 986 listings there.
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by virtualwhys on Thursday January 31, 2013 @07:11PM
(#5148358)
Thanks for the chuckle, hailing from said land of never ending brotherly love I can attest to the fact that...visiting family is about the only reason I return.
Saying that, West Cambridge and Davis Square are decent places to hide if you can afford it.
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by justforthispost on Friday February 01, 2013 @02:32AM
(#5149699)
I assume the comment above is facetious but, as someone who would like to move to the US for work, I'm curious why people living in other big cities dislike Boston?
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by tedivm on Friday February 01, 2013 @03:45AM
(#5149865)
I love Boston, but the weather can be unbearably annoying at times. Massachusetts is all about extremes, with high heat and humidity in the summer and freezing cold temperatures in the winter. Combine this with a lot of rain, snow and in between and you've got Boston.
That being said, if I hadn't moved to the bay area Boston would have been my second choice. I've spent most of my life in Massachusetts though so I'm a bit bias.
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by readme on Thursday January 31, 2013 @07:26PM
(#5148412)
My personal title: "Why I moved to New Hampshire"
As a remote worker, the cost of living in Boston is just an unnecessary expense for me. Lower taxes too. My new rent + utilities is less than 800/mo for a 2br.
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by ghc on Thursday January 31, 2013 @07:19PM
(#5148393)
I was puzzled by this too, but I think it's an artifact of the way the map is done. I live in one of those $1800+ zones and I couldn't find a 1BR on the market for under $3000 last summer. My guess would be that mean per bedroom would be $2500 in that area (including studios and economy of scale for larger places), but I bet it gets lumped in with $1800+.
Re:What The Cost Of Renting An Apartment In Boston Looks Like
by api on Thursday January 31, 2013 @08:32PM
(#5148633)
What they don't include here is the money you end up spending repairing the apartment (yes, repairing an apartment) to make it livable. At least I saw a fair bit of this in Boston. Unless you want to spend an utter fortune, you might be getting an overpriced slum.
Another extension might be a third layer that indicates travel times to a destination of your choice.
Finally, demographic information might be useful.
End result: find an affordable place, in a safe neighbourhood populated by people like you. I realise the quality of data available would make this near-impossible. Today.
(The map isn't actually 1/time-to-park-street. It's average time from each point to every other point.)
Note that it largely correlates to the WalkScore for Boston: http://www.walkscore.com/MA/Boston
I don't know why people don't make walking a bigger deal in where they choose to live in the U.S. I love driving, but
A large part of the reason I've remained in New Hampshire is because my town is extremely walkable from my house, with several cafes, good restaurants, and my work all less than 10 minutes away by foot.
(Of course there are other reasons. I "run" a large victorian-era house and rent spare rooms to friends, living for effectively free. On the other hand, I also don't know why more young professionals don't do that, because the money I save is amazing, and the only downside are more chores, or people problems if you live with friends you end up not liking)
I'm originally from Phoenix, and it was always hard to imagine walking for any reason other than exercise when I lived there.
That would be awesome.
The current code drawing code is probably too slow for this, though.
Euclidian distance away from: shops, travel, crime?
Anyone know of any papers?
The Manhattan and Euclidean distance on finite spaces both generalize to "l_p norms" (1 and 2, respectively) on an n-dimensional Euclidean space, where ||x||_p = (|x_0|^p + |x_1|^p + ... + |x_n|^p)^(1/p). You can even naturally define it in the limit where p goes to infinity!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lp_space
The price per room seems like it would be more useful if it was shown as "price per room for 1bdrm" and able to be switched to 2bdrm or 3bdrm and so on.
Breaking it down by bedroom each map would have fewer points. The most common apartment size is the two bedroom, and there are only 986 listings there.
Saying that, West Cambridge and Davis Square are decent places to hide if you can afford it.
Enjoy, it's not _that_ bad ;-)
That being said, if I hadn't moved to the bay area Boston would have been my second choice. I've spent most of my life in Massachusetts though so I'm a bit bias.
You make a good point.
As a remote worker, the cost of living in Boston is just an unnecessary expense for me. Lower taxes too. My new rent + utilities is less than 800/mo for a 2br.