Re:Systemd: The Biggest Myths
by 4ad on Sunday January 27, 2013 @10:33AM
(#5124520)
You can write software ignoring how it will be started and you (or others) can write init scripts for various traditional systems. This is way harder if you use systemd; suddenly you need to care about the init system, and you might sacrifice init independence for pragmatic reasons (I want to support systemd, but I don't want to write this yet-another-abstract-wrapper-layer so that someone else might use it with other type of init system).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
You always had to care about the init-system: There are some differences between e.g. debian and redhat (start-stop-daemon only on debian, tools for creating the symlinks to install a service), then there's upstart with a different shell-script-esque syntax.
To support systemd, the number of configs you provide will go from maybe 4 to 5, not from 1 to 2! And, looking at the examples provided by ArchLinux, the systemd services look as if they are a lot less boiler-plate than the typical debian init-script.
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Systemd/Services (e.g. dropbear is very simple)
No, generally you didn't have to care about the init-system unless you wanted to provide an init script. But it didn't matter how your daemon was/is started. With systemd that is no longer the case, you can use certain systemd only features thereby locking out people that want to use your service/daemon without systemd.
Why would systemd suddenly change this? It is one of the init systems with best backwards compatibility with sysvinit. And writing a systemd init configuration for your daemon is trivial and it is also easy to maintain.