At $13.1B AAPL made 4.5x what GOOG ($2.89B) did last quarter, And, in that one quarter, earned profits that are ~7x what AMZN has made during its entire existence.
So, yes. It's not entirely clear how "Wall Street" is assessing these tech companies against respective share prices.
"Wall Street" assesses stocks based on whether they can make money at a given valuation. Full stop. They are not investing. The are not acting as agents for investment. They are identifying and executing trades.
If you're trading, an undervalued company you can't convince anyone else to pay more for (or less for, to profit via shorting) isn't a "value".
Because it's simply not about fundamentals.
I fully expect that when Wall Street can no longer convince anyone to pay less for Apple shares, they will begin building the "Apple is unstoppable" narrative and attempt to make money on increasing share price, driving it back up to a record peak. At which point they'll start the cycle over.
Over and over. Because it keeps working.
GOOG on the other hand I think is a fair enough comparison. Actually GOOG has pretty much failed at all their attempts to make money off anything but ads, which I consider kind of worrying.
PS FYI you posted this twice and the other one is marked dead. I recommend deleting it.
Frankly, I'd love to own some Amazon stock. I think it's an amazing company with lots of potential. I just can't justify paying the current valuation. I'll probably regret it someday, but for now I'll stick with Apple and their 7 pe. Even if they lose all growth its worth much more than this. It's priced as if they are going out of business right now. I'd pay this much for either their iPhone or iPad business, not to mention having both, Mac, iPod, and anything new they come up with. They sold > 75 million devices last quarter. Doesn't exactly seem like a dying business to me.
While I have no doubt amazon can grow 5x, I do have some doubt as to timeframe. If it did it this year I'd be happy to own it at these prices. I think it's probably at least 5-10 years from that. 0-20% return over that timeframe isn't very good.
That makes amazon overpriced by, what, 25%? Which is not particularly shocking. Lots of stocks are a bit overpriced. AMZN is popular. Don't buy it. Shrug.
When you compare a 3000 P/E to a 20 P/E, you might come away thinking amazon is overpriced by a factor of 100, which would be shocking. But I don't think there's any reasonable case that it's overpriced by a factor of more than 2.
After all, this isn't some little start up that's only been going a couple of years - by tech standards Amazon is part of the old guard.
That's what Amazon is, except their assets are market share and infrastructure.
Maybe 20 years is too long for you to wait, but that's fine! The stock is priced accordingly so just cash out and let someone sweat the final liquid value of the assets.
http://www.businessinsider.com/google-generates-1-billion-on...
There is no indication that they will ever make huge profits. The Amazon you see is that Amazon you WILL see for the next 10-15 years at least.
You may be thinking of Forward P/E. But Forward P/E only attempts to project earnings out 12 months.
The E in P/E is the measure of actual earnings over time. The P/E ratio is, quite literally, the number of years required to pay back a stock's purchase price at constant dollars and earnings. AAPLs P/E ratio indicates it would take AAPL 10 years to pay back its current stock price. GOOG's indicates 20+ years. AMZN's P/E ratio indicates it would take over 3000 years to do the same.
You may be right, and AAPL's P/E ratio may be closer to 5 than where it is currently (where the drop comes from a lower stock price). But then, so should AMZN's.
I was not trying to say that the standard financial metric called P/E ratio should be calculated this way. Rather I think that ideally or principally it should be calculated this way, because what matters is "how many year will it take for me to recoup the money?", not "how many years will it take for me to recoup the money assuming that the company's earnings remains the same?".
But obviously you don't know the company's future earnings, so to make an actually computable metric you can only use the current earnings as an estimate.
Yes, this is what I mean. I'm no expert on stocks and am not familiar with the terms, but the principle should be there.
Say the "normal" P/E is around 15, which means that people think it's fair to be able to recoup the stock's price in 15 years. Now why Apple's P/E is only 10? That's because people think its future earnings will drop (in statistical sense), so that the current price will still be recouped in roughly 15 years. Similarly, Google's P/E is 20+ because people think its future earnings will rise, so that again the current price can be recouped in roughly 15 years.
Amazon's large P/E isn't that abnormal if you consider that there are plenty of companies which are losing money yet still have a positive stock price. Maybe they have lots of assets, and maybe people expect them to return to profitability soon.
For struggling large companies this can even be a gamble. If you think the company has a 5% chance of returning to glory and earn big, and 95% chance of never earning a profit again, the company can still have a pretty decent expected future earnings in statistical sense.
I've wondered about this too, but the post seems to shed some light on it. Amazon arguably has essentially no competition, while Apple, for all that it's doing well at the moment, has plenty.
(I understand the point is debatable. I'm just saying, this appears to be how the market is thinking.)
Fundamentally there isn't much point for either because it's not the right customer base. This is what branding is about, if Apple acquires a whole bunch of customers that don't care about quality and then complain that their devices don't have half-baked features it doesn't do the brand any good. These customers will destroy the brand.
I don't want to have to walk into an Apple store and wonder which is the low margin device that will fall apart / fail to perform, if I wanted to ask those questions I'd go to Best Buy.
The low margin Apple market is craigslist, if you want a 3 year old Apple device that's where you can get it.
The most confusing thing about AMZN and APPL are their respective PEs. They are priced as if each are going to adopt the other's business model.