News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by sveiss on Monday January 21, 2013 @08:59PM (#5095066)
Email delivery over SMTP works on a store-and-forward model: when you send an email, it first goes to your outgoing mail server, which then connects to a mail server at the destination domain and sends the message to it. The mail server at the destination then has the responsibility of sending the mail on to the receiving user (perhaps it gets routed through a spam filter, then to a storage server to wait until the receiving user opens their mail client).

Because the source mail server forwards the message on, it loses control of it -- the most it could do is send a "please delete this message I sent you and forget I sent it" message to the mail server at the destination domain. The destination mail server wouldn't be obliged to act on it -- it could have forgotten where it forwarded the original mail on to, or it could instead decide to send a 'Hey! Look what somebody doesn't what you to read!' message in big flashing letters to the original recipient.

AOL and corporate mail systems can implement this because they control the destination mail servers, as well as the sending mail server. On the wider Internet, you'd need to replace SMTP with a protocol whereby the message is stored near to the sender, rather than near the recipient, until the destination user reads it. There are some good arguments in favor of a system like this (it could make spammers bear more of the cost of sending their spam, for instance), but uprooting a fundamental protocol and replacing it with something else isn't an easy task to do on a network as big as the Internet.

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by csense on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @05:25AM (#5096440)
> uprooting a fundamental protocol and replacing it with something else isn't an easy task to do on a network as big as the Internet

It's a bit of work, but relatively straightforward if anyone really cares about it enough to spend effort on it.

Add a new message to the SMTP protocol that says "I have mail for you, but I'll only give you the headers right now. When the user opens it, you can call me back and ask for the content." If the target server doesn't understand the message, fall back to allowing the email to be recalled by implementing a delay.

Publish an informal protocol spec before you publicly release any code; try to get it accepted as an RFC.

Create an open-source reference implementation for the most popular open-source email programs -- mail servers, mail clients, webmail platforms. Get it accepted in the upstream of those projects.

As people start using it, they realize it's really good and start to demand it of commercial implementations. As there's a published spec, the commercial implementations end up being mostly compatible with each other and the open-source work.

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by nanijoe on Wednesday January 30, 2013 @09:13PM (#5142996)
So what happens when I try to read the email and your server is offline? I'm now stuck with the header that says "Important - Respond Immediately" without any way of getting the content
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by andrewhillman on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:41PM (#5100402)
Thanks for the explanation. Why wouldn't GMAIL, YMAIL, LIVE etc... not want this "pull back" function within their own systems - start small. Then overtime, maybe the protocol could be revised making this function interoperable.

Sometimes you just want to pull back an email and Gmails 30 second lab function is useless.

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by tectonic on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @01:29AM (#5095864)
Gmail's ability to wait 30 seconds before actually sending the email so that it can be canceled sort of provides what you want. I use it surprisingly often when I realize I want to review or re-word something that I just sent.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by 1337biz on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:34PM (#5100358)
How do I exactly do that?(canceling an email within the first 30secs)
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by andrewhillman on Tuesday January 22, 2013 @06:43PM (#5100412)
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by cail on Monday January 21, 2013 @08:13PM (#5094890)
Technical issues aside, the way AOL implemented poses some issues from SPAM I think.

With AOL I could check and if I can't unsend I know they opened the email. If this worked across all email and I wanted to use email for nefarious purposes I could use this to see, with great accuracy, exactly which email address that I've sent to were active and opened the message. I can then target these accounts more.

I feel like this could be a horrible idea.

Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by bdunbar on Monday January 21, 2013 @08:29PM (#5094949)
Because there is now way I would let Some Guy reach into the mail store on my server and fiddle around with the files there.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by unimpressive on Monday January 21, 2013 @06:30PM (#5094415)
Explain how you implement this in a standard way across providers first.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by rada on Monday January 21, 2013 @06:04PM (#5094300)
Off of top of my head: read email can be set back to "unread", email notifications (you've received an email from X) running on multiple clients such as it's open to interpretation whether email has been "delivered", client rules (move email from sender X to folder X), etc.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by Pitarou on Monday January 21, 2013 @06:20PM (#5094376)
GMail kinda has it. If you look in GMail Labs, you'll see the option to delay sending an e-mail by 1 minute. That gives you 1 minute to change your mind. I wish more mail clients had this feature.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by Mankhool on Monday January 21, 2013 @07:05PM (#5094583)
I can do it on our internal corporate mail using Exchange.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by wmf on Monday January 21, 2013 @05:36PM (#5094160)
It's extra work. Also, rules breed cheaters and then people whining about the cheaters.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by mattm on Monday January 21, 2013 @07:32PM (#5094698)
Because it's based on the snail mail system.
Re:Ask HN: Why doesn't email have a function so senders can ... by andyjdavis on Monday January 21, 2013 @09:23PM (#5095146)
This seems like it would be a big part of the reason why there is little demand for this feature. There's no recall function with snail mail. We tend to think of email as being like mail so take it as a given that it has the same limitations.