News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:34PM (#5070365)
I don't particularly disagree with that. Background checks strike me as mostly harmless but probably ineffective. It could be worth trying.

The question is whether pushing criminals toward theft would actually accomplish anything. If they still end up with largely the same number of guns, all you're doing is increasing the rate of theft, which could actually be more dangerous (especially where the criminals and the theft victims are both armed). But I guess we don't know unless we try.

I would also be interested to know whether the repeat offenders are largely gang members, because that probably changes the outcome quite a lot: A background check is a lot more likely to stop an individual felon than a gang with the manpower to knock off a gun store periodically or intimidate the owner into supplying a stream of firearms under false documents or even set up a machine shop and manufacture them internally.

Re:The President's Plan to Reduce Gun Violence by rdl on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:43PM (#5070398)
I agree somehow confiscating all guns (or even just handguns) would be a lot more effective than background checks. It's just not going to happen, though.

The repeat offenders are mainly gang, mainly drug gang. Most gangs have some sort of hazy membership procedures compared to other organizations, so you've got a lot of affiliates. (the irony here is I know about US gangs primarily due to talking with FBI/police people who were working with the US military in Iraq/Afghanistan to teach them how to go after crime/terrorism/insurgency using police tactics...)

Robbing gun stores is actually a fairly unsuccessful crime. Outside MS-13, virtually none of the street gangs operating in the US has any degree of tactical proficiency; they can't go toe to toe with police patrol officers, let alone the kind of people who tend to own gun shops (in their own territory...)

Most of the robberies for guns seem to be burglary (and in places where people are morons and leave truck guns visible in their vehicle...), or might be faked somehow (like a way to transfer by calling it a "theft", but actually being compensated). They're not against gun stores usually.

In-house manufacture is definitely a thing (and ironically you can make a full-auto open-bolt weapon more easily than a normal gun), but not generally done as much in the US due to easier availability of other guns, and brand/hollywood preference for specific types of pretty guns.