News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by api on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:32AM (#5060234)
A lot of people these days are bashing Apple and Google for creating walled gardens with their app stores, but this is really the primary reason such walled gardens have taken off. They offer a mostly crapware-free experience.

If Linux on the desktop were to get popular, I'd hate to imagine what might happen to the open source Fedora and Debian/Ubuntu repositories.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by npsimons on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:30AM (#5060541)
If Linux on the desktop were to get popular, I'd hate to imagine what might happen to the open source Fedora and Debian/Ubuntu repositories.

Nothing. In case you haven't been paying attention, Debian repositories were "app stores" before there were app stores. The software goes through extensive vetting and rigorous testing; no, I'm not saying every line of code is inspected, but to claim that a Debian maintainer would just blithely let crapware in is ignorant.

As for the walled gardens of Google and Apple, people are objecting to precisely that: the locked in, tinker-hostile way that the platform (not the app store) is managed. It's great that Google and Apple have finally seen the light and started curating software and making it easy to install, like it's been in Debian for nearly two decades. What's not great is telling people what they are and are not allowed to do with their property by anti-competitively denying the right the to install third party apps.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by binarycrusader on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:49AM (#5061160)

  ...through extensive vetting and rigorous testing...
I wanted to upvote your comment, but then I almost died laughing when I read that. Most Linux distributions are better about it now than they were many years ago, but I still remember being absolutely floored when RedHat had packaged a Perl module with a syntax error some years ago.

Same goes for Debian; some of the more "fringe packages" (those of upstream projects that haven't been updated in a while) tended to rot (compilation option changes to dependencies that silently broke parts of the program), and packages from upstream projects that changed rapidly tended to have dependency issues.

I'd also like to point out that while Debian may have had "app stores" before anyone else so to speak. The implementation left much to be desired compared to today.

Today a user simply selects an application and it gets installed. There's no prompts about whether I want the 37 additional dependencies, no text-based prompts about the configuration of some obscure package, and certainly the presentation was sorely lacking.

So yes, Debian may have had the concept early on, but as usual, Apple made something only a geek could love into something usable by everyone.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by jey on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:15PM (#5061747)
Usually there's a few tiers of packages, with the first tier packages being extensively tested and maintained, and the second tier packages mostly just provided as a convenience. I believe Debian calls the first-tier "main" and the second-tier "contrib" (and Ubuntu calls them "main" and "universe").
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by jzwinck on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @06:57AM (#5066410)
I've had breakages in Cygwin's emacs (missing GNUTLS dependency), Fedora's node.js (mismatched version of v8), GCC 4.7 (C++11 ABI regression, widely reported), Fedora 17's sssd (broke network login after upgrade), and perhaps most galling, Fedora 16's cron (which completely failed if you upgraded from 15). That's just in the past year. I don't think any of those packages are particularly niche or stale. I used to think maintainers were making miracles...now I think they're doing just OK.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by binarycrusader on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:44PM (#5062471)
Yep, I'm aware of that. Although not every Linux distribution makes that distinction and the person to whom I replied certainly didn't leave room for that.

But in the past, even the packages in the "first tier" were often pretty busted. But even for that tier, Linux distributions are not performing "extensive vetting and rigorous testing". They don't generally test beyond relying that other components that use it work as expected, and for many components, those are only as well tested as the tests that are included with the component.

Yes, some distributions do run security analysis tools or other things on the components they integrate, but that still doesn't count as "extensive vetting and rigorous testing".

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by marcosdumay on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:54PM (#5064904)
The main repository is for free software, the non-free repository is for non free software, and the contrib repository is for free softwre that you must agree to some non-free license to actualy use (because they depend on non-free software, they are just installers, or for any other reason). Those are not different tiers of software stability.

Debian has the unstable, testing and stable distros, that move on different speeds and are subject to different amounts of testing.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by dman on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @04:23PM (#5063095)
If you know of any commercial operating systems where those "fringe packages" receive greater testing than they do in debian I would love to hear about them.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by npsimons on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @10:42AM (#5067234)
Maybe I should have clarified, as some people obviously have forgotten that testing does not indicate the absence of bugs, and vetting is for many things.

I had hoped the addition of "not every line of code" would have made clear that I make no claim that every package in Debian is bug free. But I still insist, Debian extensively tests packages, mostly for compatibility and dependencies, not to mention bug squashing parties. They are also very careful about what's allowed in (due to being license sticklers).

Of course, all of this strays from my main point: the Debian maintainers are highly unlikely to let in crapware, as opposed to some stores that have had viruses. And that's just the stuff they (eventually) got rid of; don't start me on all the officially approved software that tracks users.

As for your opinion of the ease of use, well, you're entitled to it but it doesn't make it true. What's so hard about using apt-get or, if you can't use a keyboard, one of the graphical managers? So it asks you if you really want to install dependencies instead of just filling up your hard drive, and that's a bad thing? Does the Apple or Google way of "managing" packages even track dependencies, or are they still forcing every vender to include their own (possibly filled with security holes) copy of a library with their apps? I haven't had to answer a configuration question for years, and I've never had a dependency issue with Debian. I say this as a daily user of, developer on, and administrator of machines running Debian for the past twelve years.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by nitrogen on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:58PM (#5064642)
The LindowsOS app store was user friendly and based on apt/dpkg long before Apple got into the game.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by cgh on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:53AM (#5060708)
You can install whatever 3rd party software you want on a Mac, side by side with software from the App Store. Note that this article is about PCs, not mobile. You seem to be conflating the two.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by loxs on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:15AM (#5060885)
I don't see a really big difference between a PC and a phone. Don't see why one should be a walled garden and the other not.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by npsimons on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:16AM (#5060898)
Name Google's PC. The article may be about PCs, but the thread definitely devolved to talking about Android and iOS, and it's already been conceded that iOS doesn't allow third party apps. If I didn't know better, I might think you were trying to steer criticism away from Apple . . .
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by desas on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:12PM (#5062214)
You mean the chromebook?
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by lmm on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:39AM (#5060274)
Linux would probably do better because few people have any reason to stray outside their distribution's repositories. And these repositories are just as rigorous in their way as the Apple or Google walled gardens; Debian packages have to be signed by the GPG key of a debian maintainer who takes personal responsibility for that package, and whose identify has been verified by having their key signed by another debian member (with a chain that presumably goes all the way back to the original founders). I'm not aware of any cases of a debian maintainer being "struck off", but I'm sure there'll be procedures in place.

You would get plenty of shady sites encouraging you to add another line to /etc/apt/sources.list for cool free screensavers, but it would be a lot more practical than it is in windows to tell people to ignore them and never install anything that doesn't come with the system.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by jiggy2011 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:00AM (#5060380)
True, this seems like the most balanced solution. Install everything from repos but allow third party repos and stores.

That way you are not tied to one gatekeeper but it is in your interest to get your app into at least one good repo that has a reputation to uphold.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by loucal on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:50AM (#5060332)
I'm not sure that's a legit fear... Linux on the desktop in 2013 is fairly 'popular' and if it were that simple to infiltrate popular repos with spyware it would have been done years ago.

There are a ton of good people who work to keep those repos clean. Lets not trivialize their contribution by acting like anyone and their mother can make changes to the repo for a popular distro. Sure, a black[/grey] hat can make their own repository, but who in their right mind will use it?

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by flyinRyan on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:54AM (#5066745)
>Linux on the desktop in 2013 is fairly 'popular' and if it were that simple to infiltrate popular repos with spyware it would have been done years ago.

What on earth are you talking about? Linux on the desktop is just above line noise. If hackers don't bother targeting Mac's ~10% desktop share, why would they bother targeting Linux' ~1%?

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by munin on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:24AM (#5060499)
infiltrating a repo is probably not the hard part, the hard part is getting a linux app that people would want to install.

AFAIK, 0 QC or checking is done on the contents of a repo. additionally, there have been enough times in the past where someone has just straight up rooted the servers that the repo lives on ...

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by BCM43 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:40AM (#5060610)
AFAIK, 0 QC or checking is done on the contents of a repo. additionally, there have been enough times in the past where someone has just straight up rooted the servers that the repo lives on

Are you talking about debian/fedora repos? Because if so, that is simply false. Both have heavy QC, and the packages are all signed by the developers keys, and the OS checks those keys.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by danielweber on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:32AM (#5060554)
App stores are just are likely to turn to crap. I've had lots of friends complain that they bought an app, and then an "upgrade" shoved advertisements in.

It's not third-party ads, it's first-party ads, which is slightly better.

Like OP, I have a lot of sympathy for software developers trying to sell in a world full of people who don't think they should pay any dollars for software. They are still gonna pay, just in terms of their privacy and computer security.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by MBCook on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:34AM (#5060568)
I've had that happen, but the ads only show up in that one app. They can't install ads across my whole iPhone like most adware does.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by jiggy2011 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:59AM (#5060740)
May be the case on iOS but with Android I've had apps that stick extra shortcuts on my homescreen and spam notifications every few hours. This makes battery life and usability a lot worse throughout the phone until you can find and kill the offending app.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by Stratoscope on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:41AM (#5061095)
If that happens again, use one or more of these apps to find the offender:

Ad Network Detector

Addons Detector

AirPush Detector

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by eddieplan9 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:43PM (#5061533)
This is similar to saying "what stops a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun". Alternatively, you could regulate, i.e., locking down the platform and sandboxing all third-party apps.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by jiggy2011 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:47PM (#5061556)
A better alternative would be for google not to publish this shit on their store but still allow useful background notifications and allow third party manual installation.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by estel on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @04:20PM (#5063069)
With Android 4.1+ (4.0? can't remember) if you long-press on the notification it will tell you which application is responsible for it.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by krickle on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:39PM (#5064565)
I want to switch to Android, but I fear needing to have constant vigilance over what I install. Like running a Windows install but forced to use Java as well.

However, it's still preferrable to Apple's draconian policies.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by EwanToo on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:17AM (#5066839)
I've been running Android since 2.3, I've not installed a malicious app yet (to my knowledge of course).

If you want, you can install security tools which scan apps prior to being installed, like Lookout, which will alert you to various issues.

Yes there's a lot of spammy apps, but if you're even halfway aware of what you're doing, you'll have to be very unlucky to be caught out by one.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by huhtenberg on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @02:55PM (#5062551)
> They offer a mostly crapware-free experience.

You must've forgotten Path fiasco, with its quiet uploading of user's full address book to company's servers, which turned out to be - SUR-PRI-SE - a "standard industry practice". Wall garden sanctuary my ass. Same rotten ethics, except far less visible.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by flyinRyan on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @08:49AM (#5066732)
As a result, you're now asked if you want the app you installed to be able to access your address book. Do you somehow feel that exe's on windows are more transparent?
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by notahacker on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:33PM (#5061471)
If desktop Linux was widely requested by the general public, PC vendors and download sites would heavily promote custom Linux builds complete with pre-installed crapware, dubious defaults and quite possibly broken upgrade paths and most consumers would never know the difference. They'd probably have their own whored-out repositories too.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by joe_the_user on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @03:26PM (#5062759)
But Linux will never be in heavy demand as a brand. No great number of people will ever want to have Linux for the hell of it. The only way Linux could experience an upsurge in popularity would be through a mass increase in consumers' awareness of crapware and similar phenomena. And that could thus only be a small upsurge.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by csense on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @07:24PM (#5070051)
> The only way Linux could experience an upsurge in popularity would be through a mass increase in consumers' awareness

This is definitely not true. The following scenario seems to be quite possible: Due to the various problems of Windows 8, developers massively revolt and most applications are either written to older API's, or use cross-platform environments like C#, Python or Java. This essentially changes the Windows API from a moving target to a stationary target; as a result, Wine catches up -- it reaches near-100% app compatibility, perhaps with the aid of a donation from a philanthropist, Google, or some other player. OEM's recognize the cost savings possible from avoiding the Microsoft tax, and with good software compatibility now possible, they start selling discount models with Linux instead. Microsoft stops issuing new licenses for Windows less than 8 to try to pressure developers to port their stuff to Windows 8 by forcing customers to upgrade. But the move is too little, too late: The customers revolt, and since the alternative is already out of the bottle, people jump ship en masse due to lower prices and Windows 8's shortcomings.

Is this a particularly likely scenario? No. But it seems plausible, and it's not due to crapware, or consumer awareness about anything other than price tags.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by DoubleMalt on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @04:08AM (#5066046)
Some people would say Ubuntu already went down this path with the automatic installation of Amazon advertising in a pretty intrusive way (imho at least)
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @05:25PM (#5063480)
Do you use desktop linux?
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by notahacker on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @06:26PM (#5063858)
Ubuntu...
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by klrr on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:40AM (#5060277)
I'm not sure about Fedora but Debian has a very strict policy for the packages in their repos.

http://www.debian.org/doc/debian-policy/

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by jlgreco on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @12:19PM (#5061372)
As I understand it, Fedora's packaging policy is more or less the same as Debian's. Free software only (stricter than Ubuntu), though there are some practical differences. They don't like packaging emulators that are primarily useful for non-Free ROMs. It is also my understanding, different than Debian, they don't like packaging software that no longer has a maintaining developer. Also no external kernel modules, no prebuilt libraries, etc.

http://fedoraproject.org/wiki/Packaging:Guidelines#Legal

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by jiggy2011 on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:01AM (#5060388)
Open source repos should be ok, assuming that their admins don't start allowing this crap in. They haven't done so far, with the one exception of the Ubuntu amazon thing.

A risk might be drive-by malware that adds stuff to /etc/apt/sources.list though, however to do this you would need drive-by malware that can bust into the root account, or to get the user to enter the admin password.

Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @05:56PM (#5063676)
They've 'taken off' because they are the only game in town. A real test would be to provide such a 'curated' store alongside an open economy. Then that claim would mean something.
Re:Y Combinator is funding the future of spam in Windows by halo on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @01:21PM (#5061801)
There's a big difference between the iOS app store and the Android app store. One is mandatory, the other is a convenient default.