News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by azernik on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @04:45AM (#5059465)
Probably the most interesting sentence here to me (not the author's own words, but cited from another source):

"German legal ideology, moreover, is opposed to penalizing people for their own tactical mistakes."

From the news, I get the impression that the American system makes routine practice of increasing or decreasing people's punishment not for the severity of their crimes, but rather for their skill (or their lawyers') in navigating the legal system.

Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by Xylakant on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @05:05AM (#5059507)
I think one of the most important differences is that german penalties are lower[1]. Here, defendants don't face 30 years in prison. The max sentence is life sentence and even that often means 15+ years in practice, except for harsh cases or dangerous criminals.

Another point is that the costs for the defendant are lower. Watching high profile cases in the USA I have a feeling that one common point is that the prosecution does everything to bankrupt the defendant so that he has to agree to a plea bargain. In germany, the defendants costs get paid by the state if the defendant is unable to pay his lawyers. Not all lawyers would take such an engagement, but it's not uncommon that even high-profile lawyers defend people who couldn't afford them at market rate.

[1] one might argue that they're more reasonable.

Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by lispm on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @06:50AM (#5059677)
http://www.mapinc.org/drugnews/v08/n417/a04.html

Cites a New York Times article.

> Still, it is the length of sentences that truly distinguishes American prison policy. Indeed, the mere number of sentences imposed here would not place the United States at the top of the incarceration lists. If lists were compiled based on annual admissions to prison per capita, several European countries would outpace the United States. But American prison stays are much longer, so the total incarceration rate is higher.

Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by Xylakant on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @08:59AM (#5060082)
Thanks for that link. The article offers another interesting insight:

> Several specialists here and abroad pointed to a surprising explanation for the high incarceration rate in the United States: democracy.

> Most state court judges and prosecutors in the United States are elected and are therefore sensitive to a public that is, according to opinion polls, generally in favor of tough crime policies. In the rest of the world, criminal justice professionals tend to be civil servants who are insulated from popular demands for tough sentencing.

German judges and prosecutors are not elected but appointed. They're not as prone to political pressure and thus more likely to end up making unpopular decisions. The Metzler/Gäfgen [1] case is such an example: The convicted child murderer won a trial against the state because he was threatened with torture during the investigation. The decision was hugely unpopular.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnus_G%C3%A4fgen

Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by lispm on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @11:02AM (#5060767)
We can add another explanation: capitalism.

Company ran prisons are still rare in Germany. If a private company runs a prison (or several) it likes to see it filled...

Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by philippK on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @10:08PM (#5064966)
Rare ? To me - they are unheard of.
Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by Xylakant on Wednesday January 16, 2013 @09:30AM (#5066914)
There are at least partially private prisons in germany. http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justizvollzugsanstalt#Privatisi...
Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by brazzy on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @07:03AM (#5059715)
> I get the impression that the American system makes routine practice of increasing or decreasing people's punishment not for the severity of their crimes, but rather for their skill (or their lawyers') in navigating the legal system.

This seems to be a typical feature of a Common Law based system, and an incidental rather than intentional feature.

By its nature, such a system tends to become more complex over time and resist deep-reaching reform. The complexity then automatically rewards navigation skill.

Re:Land without Plea Bargaining: How the Germans Do It (1979) by jessaustin on Tuesday January 15, 2013 @09:17AM (#5060163)
incidental rather than intentional

Perhaps it was originally incidental, but at this late date both prosecutors and defense attorneys know on which side their bread is buttered. They might occasionally countenance a reduction in sentences, but they'll never allow a reduction in complexity and complication to emerge from our legislatures. Our judges all begin as prosecutors [!] so even though their livelihood wouldn't be threatened they're too professionally deformed to even recognize complexity as an issue.