Re:We taught robots to carve marble sculptures
by krisoft on Thursday November 19, 2026 @11:50AM
(#50562564)
> modeling the finished product in 3d is going to be a significant fraction of the work of actually carving it in stone.
Of course. But what is the problem with that?
We have the same situations with many other things. With printers: It takes way more effort to write a book worth printing than the actual effort of putting in the reams of paper into the printer and hitting the print button. Same with 3d printing. People spend days, weeks, months, or years modelling something interesting and then it is relatively easy to get it printed once it is designed.
> Can it sculpt something that will command your attention in reverent, slack-jawed awe for hours? I don't see it happening.
I don’t see why it couldn’t carve a model which evoke those emotions into stone. And i used my words deliberately there. Because i would call the person who made the model the sculptor. I wouldn’t say that the machine sculpted anything.
The machine is a machine. It carves the stone. We can talk about how accurately it does what it does, we can talk about the surface quality it leaves behind. We can even talk about what geometries it can or can’t tackle due to the particular arangement of the arm and the spindle.
If those “datasheet properties” are good enough, then all you need to do is get a good artist who is handy with some modelling software let them play around with it and you will get your “awe inspiring”.
Of course. But what is the problem with that?
We have the same situations with many other things. With printers: It takes way more effort to write a book worth printing than the actual effort of putting in the reams of paper into the printer and hitting the print button. Same with 3d printing. People spend days, weeks, months, or years modelling something interesting and then it is relatively easy to get it printed once it is designed.
> Can it sculpt something that will command your attention in reverent, slack-jawed awe for hours? I don't see it happening.
I don’t see why it couldn’t carve a model which evoke those emotions into stone. And i used my words deliberately there. Because i would call the person who made the model the sculptor. I wouldn’t say that the machine sculpted anything.
The machine is a machine. It carves the stone. We can talk about how accurately it does what it does, we can talk about the surface quality it leaves behind. We can even talk about what geometries it can or can’t tackle due to the particular arangement of the arm and the spindle.
If those “datasheet properties” are good enough, then all you need to do is get a good artist who is handy with some modelling software let them play around with it and you will get your “awe inspiring”.