Re:How the European Commission rolled out Matrix to more tha...
by JadedBlueEyes on Thursday November 19, 2026 @10:04AM
(#50561053)
> federation is a complete waste of time and it really adds nothing for the user
I have to say, but literally everyone using Matrix disagrees with you for various reasons. I don't have the time to enumerate all of them in a comment. Sure, it's harder, but it's worthwhile for the strategic advantages it gets you.
Re:How the European Commission rolled out Matrix to more tha...
by ezst on Thursday November 19, 2026 @10:32AM
(#50561435)
Unless OP meant "in a government/single institution set-up", in which case I agree with them.
Re:How the European Commission rolled out Matrix to more tha...
by liotier on Thursday November 19, 2026 @02:05PM
(#50564663)
Even in a government setting, ability to communicate with partners is essential - and different parts of the government might need to be administered independently. Isolated internal communications within a monolithic organization are an edge case, where centralized services are more appropriate.
Re:How the European Commission rolled out Matrix to more tha...
by timedout_uk on Thursday November 19, 2026 @07:36PM
(#50568637)
Not strictly a scientific metric, but I have had a few dozen people tell me they're holding off on deploying Venator (https://codeberg.org/matrix-venator/venator) until it gets federation support, despite it focusing on having as perfect of a local-only experience as possible before expanding the scope. Every deployment besides the demo server was just to see if it'd work and what it's like, to my knowledge, but even then they're all eagerly awaiting federation support. Nobody takes a Matrix server seriously unless it can federate, and bad federation support is worse than no federation support... so "waste of time" and "adds nothing for the user" both seem to be incorrect even without taking into account my personal experience. People really value not having a central point of failure.
1. Reliance on US tech giants is increasingly viewed as a risk and a liability by even long-term allies because of disastrous foreign policy by the current administration in particular. That's only going to increase (IMHO). We're really witnessing killing the goose that lays the golden eggs in real time; and
2. I'm sorry because a bunch of HNers really get in their feelings about this without thinking about the consequences but... federation is a complete waste of time and it really adds nothing for the user. And I really wish people would think through what this means.
Some examples:
- You have the complexity of having to send and possibly resend when a given server is down, overwhelmed or for whatever reason rejects your messages;
- Anything public basically needs to be copied to every server to accommodate search;
- Every server needs to deal with spam. You need to deal with rogue servers that enable spam. Look at email and POTS for examples of this;
- Site safety (eg monitoring for illegal materials) needs to be replicated on every node;
- If it's difficult to move node without losing everything then it's a horrible user experience;
- At which point, does somebody else effectively own your identity on the network?
- If not, how are you found? You've added a discovery problem. Is the discovery process owned by someone and effectively proprietary?
You add so much complexity by doing all of this. Just look at any accounts of people who run their own email servers. To deal with the spam issue, there is so much work that goes into avoid Gmail (etc) blacklisting you. And anybody who says "it's easy" is lying to you.