News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quad9 Is Leaving France: Why DNS Resolvers Are the Wrong ... by akersten on Thursday November 19, 2026 @12:37AM (#50556440)
I am a big fan of the reducto ad absurdum line of thinking, and I wind up completely agreeing in the abstract and idyllically it should be a pillar of how we make laws about computers, but it does paint us into some nasty corners like... well, anything on a computer can be reduced to human-readable instructions that you could get on a soapbox in the metaphorical town square and read out loud.

"Draw a pixel of color #32ab01 at position 0,0, draw the next pixel of color ..." - write enough of those instructions with specific colors and pixels and you've described (insert one's favorite example of data that is prima facie illegal to possess).

To be totally consistent in applying this line of argument, we essentially wind having to make the case that there should be no digital data that is illegal to possess or transmit. Because, it can all be described plainly in human language, and surely a sequence of innocuous, human-language instructions is protected speech.

While it makes total technical sense, it's going to be hard to publicly advance that line of thinking when most people on the receiving end of the argument boil it down to "this guy wants to make snuff films legal."

There are no comments on this comment yet.