Current-gent console market (ps6+switch2+xbox series) is about what, 200-250 million units?
That sounds like a lot, but compare this to smartphones. Apple alone sold 247 million iPhones last year. With, say, 3 year average upgrade cadence it's 600-700 modern devices all the time. Add the high-end models of Samsung and other Android vendors. This is still on-device gaming, much less demanding, where people are fine with worse graphics, lower framerate and uneven framepacing, let alone horrible controls most of the time.
And then add even more people with weaker phones, TVs, slow laptops and old-gen gaming consoles. This is the market I am talking about, and I bet for most of these users a bit of an extra lag is completely okay.
Hardware enthusiasts who are horrifies with GTA6's 30fps is a small bubble- most people will happily play it even on the series S, with drops to 25fps (and an input lag higher than most games deliver on GeForce Now)
Mario is even better as, again, things that are happening in the game are predictable, they just happen tens of milliseconds later than locally. If a game delivers 60-120fps, then playing it in the cloud could be comparable to playing the same game at 30-60fps, and it is FINE. Not amazing- just fine.
What's not fine is the price of the gaming hardware, and some people won't have a choice but to play in the cloud.
Also remember how in the 90s it was considered impossible to create a successful FPS on a console due to sticks being a bad input device compared to mouse. And indeed it was a bad input device for Quake 3, but then came Halo which was built with the gamepad in mind, with aim-assist and a large change in a game design, and it turned out that you CAN make an FPS for a console, it's just going to be a different FPS.
Maybe if we go into the cloud direction we will see a similar change in a game design?
The latency isn’t just a little extra, the frame pacing isn’t even on any service I’ve used (3), and some packet loss is common throughout. So no, it doesn’t work.
Then, earlier this year, tried GeForce now and fininshed CP 2077 Phantom Liberty just to understand the current state of the tech. It was really good.
You started with Mario, which is very playable with a huge lag, but are now switching to Celeste that is indeed an entirely different thing, and I wouldn't want to play it in the cloud, same as N++. The thing is, these games run on a toaster, and most devices suitable to be cloud gaming thin clients can actually function as hybrids.
Steam Deck will run these ultra-fast platformers well enough locally, and for anything more demanding cloud could be the way to go (it isn't right now due to how shitty GeForce now is regarding my own games even within steam library, requiring publishers to grant approval for a game to be available).
For me personally, the main drawback is the lack of ownership and control- I can't play what I already own, I can't install any mods, the game that I bought can be modified without my approval at any time. Probably that's due to my genre preferences, so obviously for you the situation may be different
It doesn’t have to be Celeste. Most Mario games would be very painful with shifting FPS, resolution, and latency.
Cyberpunk is definitely a borderline case. If you have good enough proximity to their servers and have everything hardline/perfectly set up, it is very much playable. But I could tell you that for a lot of people it would not be for all sorts of reasons. Cyberpunk is not a high precision/twitchy game at all. CoD would be unplayable for instance.
Latency is absolutely the number one barrier right now with cloud gaming. The moment a game exceeds 50-75ms or so of latency people start dropping like flies if timing is important (lots of games)
Total input lag (a time between a button press and an animation showing on your screen) isn’t just 1000ms/fps, although they do correlate.
Outside of the competitive FPS scene, most people using a gamepad can do just fine with extra 50ms of latency. Some genres hold better, some are worse (mouse lag in RTS games feels pretty shit, but no one plays these anymore).
People are adaptable