News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by hungryhobbit on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:06PM (#50552113)
>The full case against LLMs — how they’re built on unconsented labor, sold through hype, and coercively pushed onto workers — deserves its own post, which I’ll link here once I publish it.

I don't dispute that the frontier LLM companies stole vast amounts of intellectual property ... like many orders of magnitude more IP than people who are spending years in jail for piracy. That's indisputable.

But when you start equating piracy (I'm reading your book without paying for it) to SLAVERY (enforced labor) ... that's just so completely ridiculous that I find it difficult to take anything this guy writes seriously.

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by conartist6 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:33PM (#50552422)
Well they are asking us to extrapolate.

When we build something for our livelihood, they take it, tell people they made it, and that we only deserve the table scraps.

They say eventually we will thank them for their handouts and stop desiring freedom or respect or rights

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by jenadine on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:03PM (#50552844)
> But when you start equating piracy (...) to SLAVERY

They never equate it. Not even comparing it.

They just give an example of something presumably almost everyone agrees is immoral as a thought experiment.

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by hungryhobbit on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:55PM (#50554054)
Did you read what I quoted? It wasn't even from the earlier slavery part (that you're talking about).

It came much later ... but it nevertheless used the term "unconsented labor". When you use language like that ... after talking explicitly talking about slavery earlier ... it's really hard not to see it as the author contrasting piracy and slavery.

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by palata on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:49PM (#50554560)
> but it nevertheless used the term "unconsented labor"

Which you quoted as "enforced labor". Now you could say that "unconsented labour" is not really a thing, but to be fair, "enforced labor" isn't either. And if we want to nitpick, "forced labour" is not "slavery".

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by oska on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:36PM (#50554435)
There are two things that the blog author is conflating

1) The enslavement of ppl and the monopolisation of their intellectual work

2) The donation of the monopolised work to a project where all donations become available to everyone, under a Free license

Item 1 is bad. Item 2 is good (provided only that the work is good)

He's practising a rhetorical sleight of hand and his argument should be rejected as sophistry

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by Ungh on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:04PM (#50552866)
Edit: changed my point as it was stupid.

Piracy is OK as it's purely consumption. This is not piracy. It's something much worse.

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by jonhohle on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:39PM (#50553347)
In some cases it’s not even probability, it just _is_ someone else’s work with the copyright removed.
Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by palata on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:06PM (#50553649)
It drives me crazy how people genuinely cannot understand what analogies are meant to do.

NO, they DID NOT equate piracy to slavery.

They made a thought experiment to convey a point. "Imagine that we could benefit from something that we all agree was produced by unethical means, would it be ethical to do it?".

When someone says that "DNS is a bit like the phonebook but for websites" and you say "this is UTTERLY wrong, DNS is NOT made of paper", then you are the one being completely ridiculous.

The other thing being that LLMs actually do rely on low-wage workers in poor countries to do stuff you probably wouldn't want to do. So the unethical part is not only piracy.

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by hungryhobbit on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:59PM (#50554098)
Author explicitly talks about slavery, explicitly compares to slavery, and uses (separately from the slavery stuff), later on (after that slavery stuff) uses language like "LLMs ... are built on unconsented labor" ...

... and you don't think he's drawing any parallels whatsoever between slaves and how LLMs are built (ie. from piracy)?

Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by amdsn on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:14PM (#50554240)
I don't think he is, I would not interpret "unconsented labor" as "forced labor." It's an awkward phrase but if he meant the latter he would have said it. I read it as meaning LLM training takes advantage of work that was done in the past and reuses it commercially with no attribution.
Re:When Free Software Isn't Free Enough by palata on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @07:28PM (#50554357)
> Author explicitly talks about slavery at the start of the article

The word "slavery" appears 3 times in the article. Once in the quote (the analogy), and twice when clarifying that it was an analogy and nobody actually supports slavery (because, you know... people don't understand how analogies work).

> then later (separately from the slavery stuff) uses language like "LLMs ... are built on unconsented labor"

If the copyrighted work of an author serves as a building block for LLMs without the author agreeing to it, I think it's not completely weird to refer to that as "unconsented labour", is it?

> and you don't think he's drawing any parallels whatsoever

I don't.

Spoiler alert: when people talk about "piracy" in this context, there are no boats and no swords involved. Even if they happen to say "that ship has sailed" a few paragraphs after mentioning piracy.