News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Deutsche Bank by ltrg on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:01PM (#50551351)
I was involved with this project as a reporter, though others from my organisation did most of the work.

HN readers may be interested to know a bit about the tech stack. The 15 million or so documents, mostly Outlook mailbox exports, were provided to partners in the consortium via a tool called OpenAleph [1], which is maintained by DARC and based on ElasticSearch and a schema called FollowTheMoney [2], developed specifically for the investigative journalism use case. A lot of the original work on this was done by Friedrich Lindenberg (@pudo), who now runs OpenSanctions [3].

The timing was v. interesting given where we are with LLMs -- it's the first major leak I've worked on where it was possible to leverage local models to do some of the heavy lifting, and this only got more possible as the project went on. The coordinators provided a centrally hosted chatbot with RAG, but I also managed to get some surprisingly useful material using Qwen3.6-35B-A3B on my 24GB M2 MBA via a custom agent harness for Aleph/OpenAleph. [4]

Happy to answer any questions about techy stuff, though I'm not a spokesperson for the project by any means. Seen a few people saying "just release the data!", but I think that slightly misunderstands what this work is. The whole point of forming a consortium of hundreds of journalists and sifting through the dump is to identify the bits that are in the public interest to report on -- especially important in jurisdictions like the UK, where I'm based, which have very strong defamation laws. Think Panama Papers, not Wikileaks.

[1] https://darc.li/openaleph/ [2] https://followthemoney.tech/ [3] https://www.opensanctions.org/ [4] https://github.com/data-desk-eco/sift

Re:Deutsche Bank by mlmonkey on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:30PM (#50551726)
> especially important in jurisdictions like the UK, where I'm based, which have very strong defamation laws.

So, naturally, will you not err on the side of caution and not say anything that could remotely be used to file a defamation case against you? You will self-censor for the exact reasons you state!

UK is not a domain of free speech. People are being jailed for SM posts[1]. And you expect UK journalists to speak freely?

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/steveforbes/2025/09/09/people-a...

Re:Deutsche Bank by pnut on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:56PM (#50552022)
I'm not reading any US based journalists' comments about participating in this project, so why the nationalist slander?
Re:Deutsche Bank by mlmonkey on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:03PM (#50552099)
There is no "nationalist slander", I'm just responding to what they wrote.
Re:Deutsche Bank by ltrg on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:08PM (#50552917)
To be honest, you're absolutely right that draconian libel and defamation laws like we have in the UK have a chilling effect on freedom of expression, e.g. via SLAPPs. [1] But that is of course balanced against the journalist's incentive (career, love of the game) to publish the best story they can get. I've personally never experienced a situation like you describe, where less interesting stories are selected to 'play it safe'. What you'll often see instead are big stories that read a bit weirdly, or seem to lack some crucial explanatory detail, because they've been pared back by media lawyers.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_lawsuit_against_publ...

Re:Deutsche Bank by lentil_soup on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:56PM (#50552023)
I read that as, dumping a bunch of raw data without context with names of people that might or might not be bad actors can lead to defamation lawsuits in places like the UK
Re:Deutsche Bank by mlmonkey on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:07PM (#50552117)
I'm no lawyer, but here's what I think: just like the "safe harbor" provision protects carriers, if the raw data is dumped then there's some possibility of "safe harbor"-style protections; if, on the other hand, you offer up your interpretation of the data, then you open yourself up to lawsuits.
Re:Deutsche Bank by ltrg on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:10PM (#50552942)
This is exactly what I meant, thank you. There is also data protection law to consider -- we have our own version of the EU GDPR (regrettably).
Re:Deutsche Bank by user00005 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:35PM (#50553295)
Isn't that what people want with the Epstein files?
Re:Deutsche Bank by Nursie on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @11:02PM (#50555939)
That article is pretty bad.

It harps on about the old canard that a politician’s wife being arrested for a social media post - yes, one in which she directly incited the burning down of hotels full of people.

Linehan’s case was indeed police overreach, and the courts supported him and have awarded him damages.

This sort of hysterical write up is worthless, and seems only to exist to try to make Americans feel good about themselves, which right now they really shouldn’t be doing.

Re:Deutsche Bank by holmesworcester on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:35PM (#50551778)
Thank you for your work!!
Re:Deutsche Bank by cyberpunk on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:58PM (#50552773)
So let me see if i understand it right; you fed 15 million illegally obtained internal company emails from one of the worlds largest banks into a llm; and this is all you got?

Where are the crimes? Where are the actual breaches?

It’s quite sad that this is what passes for journalism these days. This is not “reporting” and you are no reporter; although I wish misfortune on deutsche as much as the next guy I do hope you have a good lawyer.

Re:Deutsche Bank by martin_a on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:11PM (#50552967)
> Where are the crimes? Where are the actual breaches?

Well, I think for a start it's a pretty big thing that Deutsche Bank CEO Sewing _actively_ helped Springer head Döpfner with evading taxes for a billion Euro deal by setting up credits and whatnot, overruling internal guidelines and warnings.

Looking to see what else bubbles up from that leak.

Re:Deutsche Bank by cyberpunk on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:30PM (#50553230)
If there was actual tax evasion, then sure -- let the heads roll. Megabank finds way to minimize tax on a big deal? Nothingburger. Happens every day.

This all just screams to me like the reporters have very little understanding on how banks actually operate and what they do (source: I work for a different european bank, and have been in banking for some years).

You'll find this behavior in all of them, none of it is news.

Re:Deutsche Bank by tstenner on Thursday November 19, 2026 @12:31AM (#50556400)
When everyone involved says "that was a complicated deal, but we're absolutely not doing it to avoid paying taxes" and the internal discussion begins with "how can we avoid paying taxes on this?" it is pretty damning.

Neither criminal tax revision nor surprising, but pretty hypocritical when they (the springer press papers) frequently rally against heat pump subsidies and social security because the state doesn't have the funds.

Re:Deutsche Bank by ltrg on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:14PM (#50553009)
You're welcome to your opinion on the findings, which led the front page of the FT today and have been picked up by outlets worldwide.

On "fed 15 million emails into an LLM", that's not quite right -- we performed targeted searches within the leak using research agents operating the same tooling human reporters were using (OpenAleph), focussed on topics which we knew would be in the public interest to report on (based on previous reporting, etc.).

Re:Deutsche Bank by cyberpunk on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:32PM (#50553262)
I'm sure that must be extremely exciting for you, but you've got several million miles to go before you're batting in the greenwald leagues.
Re:Deutsche Bank by rafram on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:37PM (#50553321)
Of all the people to name as an exemplar of real journalism…
Re:Deutsche Bank by cyberpunk on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:41PM (#50553386)
Oh I didn't mean to say he's an exemplar of real journalism, just that the snowden files were of actual substance compared to this.
Re:Deutsche Bank by rafram on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:37PM (#50553319)
> This is not “reporting” and you are no reporter

He is: https://tcij.org/person/louis-goddard/

Re:Deutsche Bank by noman-land on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:27PM (#50553200)
Curious how, specifically, you wove the local models into your process. Were you using them in agentic harnesses? Were they writing code or analyzing text themselves?

Also, presumably you used local models so the stories wouldn't leak via cloud providers but do you mind very clearly spellinf out the value proposition local models gave you for the benefit of all world people reading these comments?

Re:Deutsche Bank by ltrg on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:57PM (#50554083)
I started off just running Qwen in hax [1], a minimal coding harness, and having it use the OpenAleph API to read documents (Aleph does OCR already), emails, etc. in a free-form session based on hypotheses I had -- kind of like a smart search engine, but context length was limited so these stalled early. I then used Claude to write a harness in Swift (CLI/menu bar app, see above) that uses one model session to queue a load of tasks for short follow-ups, followed by summarisation, which generated pretty useful Markdown reports on my queries, with links through to Aleph for the originals. These mostly related to the bank's involvement with the oil and gas industry (the focus of my research).

On the value prop of local models, it's very important with projects like these to have the data touch the absolute minimum number of machines, both for security against leaks and subpoenas as you say, but also to demonstrate responsible handling practices in case of legal pushback from the subject of the investigation.

https://github.com/OleksandrChekhovskyi/hax

Re:Deutsche Bank by holgerschurig on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:36PM (#50553312)
> maintained by DARC

DARC is the german ham radio club, equivalent to use US' "ARRL". It stands for Deutscher Amateur Radio Club. It's in use since ... probably right after WW2 then ham radio was again allowed in Germany.

This is the reason why their web address is darc.li, because darc.de is used by the ham radio people.

And if I read their impressum right, they aren't some "Data and Research Center", they are "IDIO Daten Import Export GmbH" based in Berlin.

Weird.