News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by alkonaut on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:10AM (#50543833)
People (authors etc) are understandably upset about this. The models CLEARLY trained on data where they didn't own the IP. It just sort of happened too fast for laws to catch up, and now it just is what it is.

But let's assume for a moment that laws caught up. That courts decided that "no, you can't train an AI model by just scraping any content you want, and if you serve an AI model that suggests being trained on such content, you're also breaking the law".

What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy? We'd suddenly "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses, and the quality of AI models would jump backwards several years (Which on an AI timescale is like a century)?

But what if this is the "right" thing to do? Are we incapable of doing what's "right" now? Did the AI companies' bets on being quicker than legislation pay off?

Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by camillomiller on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:18AM (#50543891)
That‘s been Silicon Valley‘s MO for about three decades
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by philipwhiuk on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:22AM (#50543922)
> What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy? We'd suddenly "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses, and the quality of AI models would jump backwards several years (Which on an AI timescale is like a century)?

Yes? There's going to be a cataclysmic change to the economy when the money runs out anyway. Why should these brand new companies who skirted and ignored the law get a free pass. Is it really sensible to have environment where you can become too-big-to-fail in less than a decade because a dozen guys with cash decided it should happen?

Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by alkonaut on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @04:30AM (#50544000)
I think the problem here, as always, is "But what about China?"
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by account42 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:05AM (#50544283)
What about them? That argument hasn't had any impact on IP laws before so why should it now?
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by alkonaut on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:22AM (#50544409)
If we outlaw these models, but Chinese companies don't, then companies like Deepseek who offer models based on it would need to be banned in the west just like the sale of conterfeit Gucci bags is. It's just fair trade policy. But the end result of that is basically that we accept that "western" models, and the models available to all of western industri are much worse than what Chinese companies use. E.g. Chinese software development firms get Opus 5.5 level AI help, while everyone at US software firms get AI agents that are 2023 level. Those US firms would quickly realize that offshoring pays massively.
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by account42 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:28AM (#50544464)
You don't just ban the unethical technology but also ban imports of goods created with it. The same is true with other immoral "tools" that greatly benefit companies like slaves or just dumping your waste wherever or mixing in unhealthy chemicals into your food to make it look better.
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by alkonaut on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:54AM (#50545190)
In the end, I think it would be extremely difficult to have such a "taint" rule for (for example) software. It would essentially be a complete ban with cooperation with companies outside the great-ai-wall of the west. Having a management consultant from India? big no no because his recommended reorg might have run through Deepseek.
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by consumer451 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:02AM (#50544260)
I don't think this is about training, it's about creating an "AI summary" specific enough for a particular query, that the user never clicks the citation link and visits the website.

Or, am I misunderstanding what is TFA is about?

Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by alkonaut on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:19AM (#50544388)
Yes they're two related things. Google always crawled and indexed, and an index could always show a "summary" e.g. the first paragraph of the page in search results. Some news outlets were upset even before AI that the summaries were too long/detailed that users never had to click.

An Ai just supercharges that problem. The "AI summary" can basically leave people with no reason to click the link.

The other thing is the "AI answers", i.e. when there is an answer at the top of a search result which answers the search query as an LLM answer, potentially wiht some links etc. That could suggest it's actually taken from training data rather than just page summaries.

Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by account42 on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:03AM (#50544271)
Whe should absolutely "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses if they are making things worse for everyone else. Not doing that sends the message that the law doesn't matter if you can scale up quickly and become too big to fail. That would be an even more devastating position for society to take.
Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by ornornor on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:16AM (#50544871)
> that the law doesn't matter if you can scale up quickly and become too big to fail

That’s exactly the world we live in though, and have for a long time.

Why are we still burning fossil fuels on the scale we do? Why are we still selling cigarettes and alcohol on the scale we do? We are we still giving so many subsidies to tech businesses, or older businesses (like Walmart, McDonalds etc) through food stamps? Why is the orange man still in charge of destroying the civilized world despite so breaking so many laws and open corruption? Banks bailed out after they get in trouble by being reckless and breaking the financial system?

The list is endless. Rules don’t apply if you have enough money.

Re:AI is killing All About Berlin by geraneum on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @05:55AM (#50544681)
> What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy?

Ah we’ve entered the too big to fail era of AI corporations even before they turn a profit. How nice.