News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:H-1B Executive Actions in 2026 [pdf] by zanderwohl on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @12:15AM (#50542145)
I agree that a lot needs to change about the H-1B program, but I don't love how much of it has come from executive orders and worse: just offhand statements that drive employers into anxiety and uncertainty. Uncertainty is just the worst thing for the market (and my own salary prospects). The $100,000 fee felt like it was rolled out in jolts. Who was affected? Who was exempt?

At least with laws passed, we see it coming from a long way away. IMO, congress should reduce the powers the executive branch can just wield on this or that, and set the agenda, rather than letting the agenda be set by the president every 4/8 years.

Re:H-1B Executive Actions in 2026 [pdf] by dmitrygr on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @12:35AM (#50542265)
1. "I agree a lot need to change"

2. "we need make sure to take power away from $entity_changing it and give it to $entity_who_has_had_decades_and_fixed_nothing"

3. ???

4. profit

how do you expect change if you keep asking for the entity who has had ample time and fixed nothing to have more power?

Re:H-1B Executive Actions in 2026 [pdf] by samrus on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:25AM (#50542549)
You gotta take a civics class. You cant move fast and break things with legislation. The precendent of the executive branch disturbing the balance of power by making laws and policy like this is not worth the benefit of this one issue being expedited. We need to have congress solve this problem because that maintains the balance of power
Re:H-1B Executive Actions in 2026 [pdf] by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:30AM (#50542586)
Civics class isn’t going to make Congress functional. The evidence is the executive branch can do a lot of what it’s done, and if Congress does nothing, there are no consequences for doing so.

Balance of power only exists if you allow it to, if you have power. If you can’t be or aren’t bound by a counterbalance, there is no balance of power, its honor system.

Re:H-1B Executive Actions in 2026 [pdf] by tourmalinetaco on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @03:58AM (#50543734)
I think you’re the one who needs a civics course. These are powers vested in the executive since this country’s inception, and this is hardly the first time they have disturbed the “balance of power”, especially when almost every EO this administration has put out has been judicially challenged at every point, whether the challenge had actual legal standing or not.

I agree that congress should speak on this (and codify more strict immigration laws), but EOs are only enforcing the powers within the executive branch, not creating new laws. When they restrict an agency’s abilities or empower them, these are simply internal orders within the executive branch, in large part because no singular law or laws govern agencies and defines their explicit day-to-day. EPA, DEA, and NSA are all examples of executive-led agencies made without explicit law codifying their creation. And, such as with H1B, even when the legislation created it the laws are loose enough to give the executive full legal control without disturbing anything from a civics perspective.

Congress spoke in ‘52 and set the ceiling. Executive speaks today and tells you how that ceiling will be reached, if at all. Judicial speaks tomorrow and ensures that orders from today follow the rules from ‘52, and due to the current laws they do.