I very much doubt a person functions any better with a smartphone versus without. Communications can usually wait, and if they can't, voice is still better.
Outlook is a bad example, because its filters are too dumb.
GMail does a pretty good job of maintaining its built-in filters automatically. So filters might be a compromise worth going for.
Going without a smartphone might be better in the long run. But that will be a harder sell to people than good filters.
I think people are starting to lose interest in smart phones. There is a rapid decline of them in my organisation (150 people). We've gone from all staff having them to about 90 users in the last year. The rest are back on cheap phones.
> I've not found Gmail or Outlook filters to be different to each other in any significant way.
Recently, GMail has introduced statistical filters for some predefined categories. Like Notifications, Social Updates, and a few more.