News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by happytoexplain on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @04:08PM (#50538216)
I don't think the definition is necessarily racist, except in the casual sense where we tend to over-apply the word. Regardless, this seems like a semantic argument. Which is fine, I don't have a strong feeling about what exactly the word "zionism" maps to, but it does mean there is no "right" answer until usage dictates one, and clearly usage is in flux at this point in history.
Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by danielklnstein on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @04:11PM (#50538243)
The point is not whether the definition is racist or not - that would indeed reduce the discussion to a semantic argument about the definition of what racism means, that's not the point.

Do you disagree with the notion that whoever changed the definition - and yes, it was changed - did so with the purpose of influencing public opinion against Israel? Do you disagree that the definition - as currently written - will tend to bias the reader against Zionism (and by extension, Israel)?

That's the core issue here.

Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @06:30PM (#50539725)
> Do you disagree that the definition - as currently written - will tend to bias the reader against Zionism…

Is that a problem with the definition, or present-day Zionism?

Should apartheid's definition be revised to avoid bias or influencing public opinion against the South African regime that put it into place?

Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by danielklnstein on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:24AM (#50542540)
Again, that's not the issue discussed under this current article.

It seems like you yourself think that the definition should bias the reader against Zionism and Israel.

And given the fact that the definition was modified in this manner during the current war, it's clear that there are editors on Wikipedia with an anti-Israeli agenda. I think you'll agree that it's highly doubtful that whoever added that appendix to the article did so for neutral reasons.

So clearly there's anti-Israeli editors on Wikipedia, with demonstrable and long-lasting changes to key articles done by those editors - so in the context of the current article, I would ask (1) why is it wrong for there to be a counterparty to those efforts and (2) where are examples of edits committed by pro-Israeli editors that were done to influence public opinion in favor of Israel?

Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by ceejayoz on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @06:59AM (#50545233)
> Again, that's not the issue discussed under this current article.

You brought the definition of Zionism up, now it's off-topic. Huh.

> It seems like you yourself think that the definition should bias the reader against Zionism and Israel.

Should a reader of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamas be neutral on the subject after reading? Should every Wikipedia article be held to this standard, that you end the read with zero feelings for/against the subject? Should the article on Hamas leave you (correctly) biased against them?

> And given the fact that the definition was modified in this manner during the current war, it's clear that there are editors on Wikipedia with an anti-Israeli agenda.

Or, starting a giant regional set of wars of aggression and flattening Gaza and having prominent Israeli government officials get all genocidey in their public statements added some new evidence.

Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by danielklnstein on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @08:04AM (#50545843)
I'm either doing a poor job of making myself clear - or you're doing a poor job of displaying basic reading comprehension. I think it's the latter.

You're ignoring the main point of this thread - which is that Wikipedia's articles have been influenced by anti-Israeli editors who are seeking to push anti-Israeli narratives.

Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by slowin on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:04AM (#50546477)
The Wikipedia articles are factual though. That’s like saying Wikipedia is anti-Nazi because it portrays them in a bad light. No, it’s that Israel’s actions are abhorrent and Zionists don’t like to see their reflection, especially when they know others can see it too.
Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by danielklnstein on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @09:42AM (#50546906)
If you read the opening paragraphs on Nazism and Nazi Germany in Wikipedia, you'll be hard pressed to find a single thing that's cast in any substantial doubt, or lacks any true scholarly consensus.

That same statement is not true of the Zionism article. Whether you agree or disagree there are substantial and credible bodies that don't agree with the written definition Zionism - in fact, open your local dictionary, turn to Zionism, and you'll see a different definition.

So calling something that lacks even close to broad consensus "factual" is a stretch.

> No, it’s that Israel’s actions are abhorrent and Zionists don’t like to see their reflection, especially when they know others can see it too.

As a Zionist, I'm proud of my reflection, and in the same way that Resolution 3379 was a stain on the UN fed on lies and propaganda - and was eventually rescinded - I'm confident that whatever smears seem to have influenced your own opinion on the matter will eventually be reconciled as well.

Re:Israel vs. Wikipedia by slowin on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @10:25AM (#50547440)
There’s nothing in the page about Zionism that casts any doubt.

> As a Zionist, I'm proud of my reflection

If that was true you wouldn’t be here lying about Zionism.