News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by WJW on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:03AM (#50533314)
Simple counterexample to show how this overly simple rule immediately falls down when applied to even the smallest bit of critical thinking: what about gender reassignment surgery? I don't want people to do that to me (and I assume this is true for most surgeons who perform such procedures), yet others very much want it done to them.
Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by whimblepop on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:09AM (#50533441)
Kant's formula isn't vulnerable to this particular criticism because a maxim isn't the individual action and universal laws aren't about you in particular. The more quotidian formulations of the "silver rule" point at the same thing but with language that leaves more of the work of figuring that out to the interpreter. This is an interpretive failure on your part.
Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by thfuran on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:19AM (#50533656)
A phrasing that requires the reader to infer something that simply wasn’t implied is a failure to communicate on the part of the author.
Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by whimblepop on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @12:27PM (#50534908)
I myself prefer Kant's formulas because I think it's clearer, and it strikes the ear with enough alienness that it signals that something technical and precise is meant, and that understanding it requires considering the wider meta-ethics in which the formulas figure.

But this is also a matter of genre. Aphorisms are... aphoristic. That means they tend to be laconic and ambiguous. Part of the interpretive competency here is recognizing the genre and then reading the saying accordingly.

You're right that this kind of non-transparency is a weakness of aphorisms and slogans, though.

Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by Felk on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:15AM (#50533563)
Surely you can put your example in a more favorable interpretation: I wouldn't want a gender reassignment surgery categorically denied to me (whether I want it or not), so I also shouldn't deny it to others.

Another popular political example which projects onto people close to you: if you wouldn't be okay with your spouse being denied an abortion, you should not advocate against abortion rights for others. If you're biologically male, it obviously doesn't matter whether _you_ could get an abortion, but the spirit of the rule holds.

Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by t_e_s on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:16AM (#50533585)
Surely you don't think the rule applies that literally? Would you expect others to eat when you are hungry?

The rule is just "do medical stuff to people if they want it"

Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by WJW on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:48AM (#50534214)
I don't actually think the rule should apply literally, but sadly it is often repeated as if it is, with no ifs and buts attached.
Re:Loopholes Are for Assholes by nadis on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:20AM (#50533662)
I might be misunderstanding your point but I don't think this is such a valid counterexample because it's misapplying the principal in an overly specific and incorrect way.

The universal wants in your example that would apply the principal are (1) access to healthcare providers (surgeons want access to a surgeon if/when they need an operation) and (2) bodily autonomy (I want to be able to choose whether or not I get such a surgery and have that choice be respected and applied).