News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by monk_grilla on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @12:53AM (#50527923)
I'm surprised that you didn't independently answer your own question in the course of writing it. You were so close.

There are many factors a consumer considers when choosing a product. By choosing one product over another, one of the factors at play is that the consumer is directly financially benefiting the company and individuals behind it. It is not unreasonable to assume that when one of those companies or individuals take a morally apprehensible public position on issues that matter to the consumer, that will make them less likely to choose that product from among their options.

Alternatively, and this might be more controversial, depending on the nature of the things shared by the company or people involved with the company, a consumer might make some well-founded extrapolations about their competencies in producing a good product and providing good service for it.

For example: one might distrust a pharmaceuticals company whose leadership expresses their support for anti-vax conspiracy theory; a transgender person or racial minority might reasonably think they'd receive worsened support from a service who is publicly against their existence or status; a rational person might distrust the cognitive abilities of a MAGA supporter in 2026, thereby making their product a less appealing choice.

> *Everybody. Everybody has wrong moral ideas.

Sure, no-one is perfect. Does that mean I shouldn't factor in what I consider to be morally reprehensible behaviour by leadership when choosing a product or service? Also, I'm not really sure how you defined a "wrong" moral idea... seems like a difficult term to define.

Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by card_zero on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @11:37AM (#50533991)
So yes, that sounds like "I want to punish my ideological enemies". (I don't think their bigotry actually makes their e-ink display less functional, that's silly.)

I think all our ideas (moral or not) are very likely wrong, because of progress. Even after improving them, they're still wrong. So we could all be punishing one another for being imperfect, all the time. That's an unpleasant state of affairs. To some extent I suppose it's happening.

Somebody else in a comment said "evil". So we have the idea of using coercion that's allowed by law (such as ostracism) to punish people who are evil in ways that are also allowed by law (such as being prejudiced). Why punish them, though? Why be coercive instead of using words? Why even attempt to change that specific individual's head, in unreasoning ways, which may be a lost cause, instead of discussing the ideas with receptive people? The evil person may or may not come around in time. What does fighting with them get you?

Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by monk_grilla on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @06:42PM (#50539844)
> that sounds like "I want to punish my ideological enemies"

Not "punish" so much as "not voluntarily support".

> I think all our ideas (moral or not) are very likely wrong, because of progress. Even after improving them, they're still wrong. So we could all be punishing one another for being imperfect, all the time.

I mean this is true throughout human history though, right? This is the natural progression of society and culture. After World War II society at large decided that the ideas of the Nazis were not acceptable, and those who clung to them were ostracised and (in this case) punished. That is how human society works. In the days of the hunter gatherers, a member who consistently took more than their share would be punished or excluded from the tribe. That is how we maintained order and how we alone among the animal kingdom dominated the planet through our ability to cooperate in larger numbers than any other species.

A large part of the population has decided that they don't accept the level of bigotry displayed by this person. They exert their free will to not do business with them, as is their right.

> Why be coercive instead of using words?

I mean you can do both if you're so inclined. And I think it is weird to imagine doing the words without the boycott. Like would you go into Hitler's Baked Goods and try to talk him out of Nazi ideology while purchasing an armful of pastries?

I don't think that choosing not to buy from a bigot is really a coercive attempt to change their mind, which is sort of how you frame it. It is just not supporting that particular person and by proxy their ideology. It is like choosing a local small business over a massive chain. You do it because you want to support one and not the other, and maybe because your support for one or other of them will benefit their respective communities.

(For the record, I didn't downvote you. I don't even know if I'm able to do that.)

Re:Frame – 31.5" color ePaper display by card_zero on Wednesday November 18, 2026 @01:07AM (#50542435)
> That is how human society works

This phrase should prompt skepticism, don't you think? Does human society, throughout history, work in any particular way? It rather seems to fly by the seat of its pants. The history of civilisation is one in which civility increases, in fits and starts. Back in the era of King Scorpion the First, when might made right, I expect his greatest argument was a mob of supporters armed with clubs, but these days he would be an enemy of civilization. We limit the "coercive attempt to change their mind" to dire situations, with the goal of maintaining the free and uncoerced use of minds.

So, cutting to the chase, is this concept of customer "support" a good idea or a bad one? It's comedic to say "Hitler's Baked Goods" because it juxtaposes war with civility. But if I choose an ISP because I like their ethics, or I donate to a charity because I want them to promote something, am I engaging in low-key war? Does my attempt to circumvent open discussion oppose the civil values of an open society? It's fashionable these days to cut off one's friends and family because they took the wrong side in a moral debate. Is that low-key war? Is it different from picking and choosing between businesses on ethical grounds (unrelated to what you get out of it)? Is preferentially giving to one charity the same sort of thing as refusing to speak to somebody?

I can tell these are silly questions, and there must be a key concept at the heart of it. I'm puzzled.