News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by bradleybuda on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:27PM (#50520992)
The GDP of Michigan is $734B. The combined cloud computing revenues of Google, AWS, and Microsoft (which make up a large fraction of this datacenter work, though not all of it) are $290B. So yes, we should expect the power usage of these things to be in the same order of magnitude.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by shimman on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:36PM (#50521118)
No, I wouldn't expect that at all. Google, AWS, and MSFT do not care about helping society. They do not care about making sure children get a good public education. They do not care that workers are treated with dignity. These three can't even bother to hire Americans for jobs in America. They just care about making money.

The state of Michigan provides more value for humanity than those three companies easily.

In fact we should explicitly tax those companies to provide free public school lunches, universal childcare, and universal college/secondary/vocational training programs.

For fun, look at what these three companies are explicitly paying for their data center build out and look at the cost of what it would cost to provide every American school child free lunch.

These companies are sick and should be justly destroyed.

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by richwater on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:40PM (#50521174)
> should be justly destroyed

Ah, the truth emerges. The smokescreen about taxes, appeal to emotion, etc are all just rooted in that you want to seize and destroy companies you personally disagree of.

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by Computer0 on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:05PM (#50521532)
Who’s side are you on? Seizing and destroying is the peaceful option that will be presented.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by bluedino on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:44PM (#50521227)
> These three can't even bother to hire Americans for jobs in America. They just care about making money.

Are you talking about the auto companies?

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by jayGlow on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:23PM (#50521799)
we already tax these companies besides that the US spends on average around $17,500 annually per student among the highest in the world. How much more would we have to spend to provide free lunches for everyone? is there any guarantees that if we increased taxes we would actually solve these issues?
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by viklove on Monday November 16, 2026 @04:49PM (#50523812)
> we already tax these companies

Not enough.

> US spends on average around $17,500 annually per student among the highest in the world

Services cost more in the US, so of course it will be more expensive to educate students in America.

> How much more would we have to spend to provide free lunches for everyone?

Nine U.S. states already provide free school lunch (and breakfast) to all public elementary, middle, and high school students regardless of family income. Some quick math shows it would cost Michigan ~$500M/year to provide free lunch to all elementary school students (assuming all students take advantage of the free lunch, so it might be lower).

> is there any guarantees that if we increased taxes we would actually solve these issues?

Nothing in life is ever guaranteed, but the money is definitely there and with the right legislators it could easily be done.

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by fooqux on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:12PM (#50524140)
No need to do the math. Michigan has free food for students and one simply has to look at the budget to see it only cost $248.5 million.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by qeternity on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:16PM (#50524180)
>Not enough.

Oh, this again. Why should we tax these companies differently to any other?

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by fooqux on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:47PM (#50524584)
We already tax differently based on tax brackets. I don't see why a few new ones can't be created. I shouldn't be taxed the same as Musk, and Bob's Landscaping shouldn't be taxed the same as Amazon.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by qeternity on Monday November 16, 2026 @05:14PM (#50524167)
>These three can't even bother to hire Americans for jobs in America.

They are some of the biggest employers in the US...what are you on about?

>They just care about making money.

Yes, that is literally the purpose of a company. It's like saying "employees only care about their paycheck".

>These companies are sick and should be justly destroyed.

Ah right. Having a normal one today are we?

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by missedthecue on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:45PM (#50521245)
Why calculate the cloud computing revenues and not the economic activity facilitated by the existence of cloud computing? You're measuring multiple orders of economic activity by using Michigan GDP but only one order using google, aws, and msft cloud revs.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by bradleybuda on Monday November 16, 2026 @07:51PM (#50525919)
It’s a very high level calculation that I could do in 60 seconds to see if the article is saying something interesting or not. It’s definitely incomplete and those datacenters are probably powering much more economic activity. Doing this analysis would be helpful but I suspect not very enlightening.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by coryrc on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:18PM (#50521715)
We're also not counting the petroleum powering the cars everyone is driving and the natural gas used as the primary source of building heat.

Electricity is useful for so many things, but it's not needed in huge amounts in an ordinary Michigander's life today. I wish they'd switch to EVs and heat pumps though, but electric rates make the latter cost more (EVs are cheaper).

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by bluGill on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:25PM (#50521815)
Michigan should install heat pumps. However it gets cold enough that a heat pump will not work for several days every winter (and even more nights), so while heat pumps will help they still need something and natural gas ends up our best bet...
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by keybrd-intrrpt on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:29PM (#50522767)
> However it gets cold enough that a heat pump will not work for several days every winter (and even more nights)

This says they are still viable:

https://michiganhvacauthority.com/michigan-heat-pump-conside...

Modern residential cold-climate air-source heat pumps can operate down to roughly −15°F to −25°F, depending on the model.

Michigan had an average of 4.6 nights per year reaching 0°F or below during 2020–2024

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by bluGill on Monday November 16, 2026 @03:36PM (#50522886)
Average is useless number for this discussion. One night ever - even it is is one in 100 years - of less than -25F is serious. That will happen at least once in the next 20 years - I don't know when, but it will.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by AnthonyMouse on Monday November 16, 2026 @04:12PM (#50523355)
Heat pumps are nearly always backed by resistive heaters for exactly that reason. Resistive heaters are extremely cheap in terms of capital (they're basically just a medium resistance piece of metal) but use more electricity than heat pumps. Which is expensive if you were trying to use them every day, but kind of a shrug if you only have to use them one day out of a decade.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by positr0n on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:14PM (#50527353)
But if an entire state suddenly switches to resistance heating once a decade the grid will not be able to handle it. That's a lot of capacity to keep around to use once every ten years.
Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by AnthonyMouse on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:42PM (#50527536)
The demand on the grid isn't constant to begin with. That's why it needs some kind of peaker plants or storage or similar. And then on that day the peaker plants you usually run for 4 hours a day at 80% load are getting run full out for the full 24 hours etc.

Moreover, for that one day out of the decade, the price of electricity is going to be high. And then nobody is going to want to pay that price to top up the last 25% of the battery in their electric car, they might even be sellers at that price. They're also not going to be inclined to do any aluminum smelting or set their electric heat thermostat to 85 F. If they have a "backup generator" for power outages (as many commercial businesses do), they're going to find it profitable to turn it on rather than paying the grid price that day. And so on.

It's not a question of whether you can do it, it's a question of what's the best way to make it so you only have to lean on demand pricing a little instead of a lot when the day comes.

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by coryrc on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @01:10PM (#50535644)
I bring this up all the time, especially in context of people saying "solar is the cheapest so it solves all problems!!!". Most energy use in the North is heating and is predominately fossil fuel. If we want to decarbonize, we must have a solution for heating cold winters in the suburbs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_Landing_Solar_Community is by far the cheapest solution for about 80% of the Midwest, but it's a collective solution and so we wouldn't do it. Solar would only work if we ran HVDC lines from the Gulf and added significant storage, but then it isn't so cheap anymore. Nuclear co-located near heat users (city centers) could also be cost-efficient in a different regulatory environment, but we are no longer able to efficiently build large projects. And natural gas is cheaper both per-unit and cap-ex, so without significant carbon taxes (which people will vote against) there's no economic drive to decarbonize.

Anyway, resistance storage heaters with central control can prevent grid collapse if we ever got significant uptake on heat pumps in the Midwest, which we won't.

Re:Just 400 US Data Centers Use More Electricity Than Michigan by coryrc on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @01:01PM (#50535468)
It's not, because of both thermal inertia and they can still produce some heat at a lower output temperature. And also most of Michigan doesn't get that cold.

It's that the power regularly goes out that's far more a problem than the once-in-ten-years cold night.