News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia Was in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess by jmyeet on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:10PM (#50520778)
I don't agree with this.

One of Tim Apple's [sic] big innovations was to take Apple's giant pile of cash and use it for vendor financing. Building a new fab or process or factory is expensive. Borrowing money is expensive and risk. But Apple gave favorable terms in exchange for a period of exclusivity to whatever the vendor produced. This was huge for the iPhone for years.

NVidia is kind of in that position now. One can say that there is circular financing between NVidia and the big AI companies but is it really that different to Apple's approach? I'm not entirely convinced that there's an imminent domino effect collapse coming as a result of all of this. And, even if it does, I don't see it taking down NVidia.

Boeing (and Airbus) is the other company NVidia reminds me of. The business of selling planes is complicated. Boeing gets to throw its weight around and demand concessions. Launch partners for new planes get favorable delivery dates but that's also a chain. Qatar Airways famously went to war with Boeing and lost its A321 orders. That's the kind of power NVidia has now over the AI providers. It gets to decide who gets to buy and when.

As for competitors, there are always wannabees. Remember the decade of Google killers? I do. What happened to them all?

It surprises me on HN of all places how many people think you can vibecode a GPU competitor to NVidia, basically. I'm sorry but no. Chip design is harder than that. Managing relationships with suppliers, vendors, the fabs (particularly TSMC), etc is hard. NVidia has been doing it a long time, has a lot of built up expertise and has a lot of volume and weight it can throw around.

Jensen Huang was correct about China (IMHO). Restricting the chipmaking from ASML is one thing. Restricting the chips was a mistake in foreign policy terms. It has created captive domestic demand for Chinese chips. And it's too late to unring the bell. Xi Jinping realizes that chipmaking and AI is of national security interest to China. Yes there'll be some smuggling in the meantime but I fully expect China's EUV to be producing commercial chips by 2030. China simply doesn't want to be beholden to Western companies in the exact same way that most US tech companies were banned in China. I believe history will vindicate Xi's long-term strategic thinking in this area (yes, blocking the likes of Facebook and Uber predated Xi, I know).

I also think AI isn't going to be ASICed anytime soon like crypto mining was. Crypto had a fixed algorithm. AI does not, at least not yet. It's constantly changing. Even in recent years we've tried different quantization methods (eg fp4, int4). Model architecture is still evolving at a rapid rate. It's way too early to fix that into hardware.

Re:Nvidia Was in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess by MisterMunchkin on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @03:01AM (#50528700)
Apple was supporting their suppliers so that they could buy more supplies from them. Nvidia is funding their own sales to customers.
Re:Nvidia Was in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess by 14113 on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @08:22AM (#50531007)
> Chip design is harder than that

Chip design is not NVIDIA's advantage, or at least, it wasn't the advantage that "won" it the AI race. NVIDIA's advantage is the quality of the software ecosystem that surrounds the hardware. That is (arguably) a less secure moat.

Re:Nvidia Was in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess by rsynnott on Tuesday November 17, 2026 @09:21AM (#50531778)
Funding _suppliers_ to expand their operations is not that unusual; while Apple's maybe unusual in how much it does it, it's hardly the only company doing so (and it's also not new; literally centuries old). Funding purchasers to buy your stuff, outside of certain consumer businesses (notably cars) _is_ very unusual.