The allegation is that a consensual relationship took place.
And yes, if your value to the company exceeds the liability of a direct report suing, then yeah feel free to date them. Like why is this even confusing to people.
Hr is about cost and risk management not moral policing
I made no such allegation. I will say, consent is strained in a relationship with a power imbalance. And there's at least the appearance of a conflict of interest, even if no conflict arose.
All that said, the risk of a harassment lawsuit re harassment from the CEO would seem to be increased if the CEO is having intimate relationships with direct reports.
The question was about the risks and benefits of keeping a CEO in that case. I'm saying, go ahead and ignore the risk of the direct report(s) suing because the CEO is so important... the risk to the company from keeping the CEO who had an initimate relationship with a direct report is that (some) downstream managers will take the message that pursing intimate relationships with direct reports is company approved and harass their direct reports trying to form those relationships, and juries will also see the messaging from the company that this was company sanctioned. You'll have more harassment issues, every harassment case will cost more because it's a pattern of behavior, and you'll lose staff that don't want to work where harassment is a problem.
That seems pretty darn expensive to me. Maybe he's some superduper CEO, but I don't think any board voted in by institutional investors is going to let it slide.
And preventing scenarios that could lead to coercion, or allegations thereof, is basic risk management.
It also gives everyone a slam dunk lawsuit when anything doesn’t go their way. Passed over for a promotion? You’re settling for millions.
The lawsuits from CEO harassment might not be too bad, but cleaning up from the rest of them will be, because juries are going to award more damages because there's a pattern of the company doing nothing if the CEO does it and has no consequences.