Re:Linux was created as a rejection of robust software archi...
by 7373737373 on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:16AM
(#50514316)
I strongly doubt this is (still) true. Most devices are networked now. What is 10% less performance, in exchange for proper security? I would switch in a heartbeat. The only problem is that existing microkernel projects are not exactly usable yet. That their research, development and adoption are not more strongly funded and supported seems strange to me. As a programmer, OF COURSE i'd like to prefer to work with systems that gave me fine grained guarantees about resource (file system, network, CPU, memory) access, -isolation and -consumption.
Re:Linux was created as a rejection of robust software archi...
by grapheneos on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:48AM
(#50514764)
Microkernels are incredibly widely used. They're used on many of the components used in a modern computer including radios for cellular, Wi-Fi/Bluetooth, GNSS, NFC, etc. Many components are now written in a more secure way than mainstream general purpose operating systems. macOS and iOS have also gradually been moving more towards microkernel design by moving code out of the kernel. They started from a foundation where that was part of the design but not heavily used.
Re:Linux was created as a rejection of robust software archi...
by zbentley on Monday November 16, 2026 @12:31AM
(#50514379)
The main reason Linux succeeds is network effects. Once everyone has been coding to Linux/POSIX APIs for upwards of 35 years, the ability to move to something else is incredibly limited. Even if a new OS attracted 100% mind share for all new development, it'd take many, many years for it to approach even the beginnings of ubiquity that Linux had in the early 2000s.
Re:Linux was created as a rejection of robust software archi...
by grapheneos on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:49AM
(#50514774)
Replacing the Linux kernel ABI isn't necessary to have a microkernel written in a memory safe language. It can provide the same ABI. gVisor is not what we mean but shows it's doable.
Anyone who studies kernel development long enough will eventually say micro kernels are much safer, we have better languages now, or there are better ways to access OS resources, and they’re sort of right. But the reason Linux succeeds is because it focuses on being the fastest, fully featured kernel, and that’s what people actually wants. There are dozens of alternatives that nobody uses because at the end of the day, nobody cares if your language is “safer” and your drivers don’t have kernel access if it’s 10% slower when reading IO. They’ll just stick with Linux