News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by tim-projects on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:19AM (#50508109)
I have some projects I've been working on over a year. Sitting down working making design decisions. Research. Using ai doesn't mean I did no work. It doesn't matter if the ai was trained. I still did work.

I don't understand this view point. Using ai and making high quality stuff is not pushing a button. Its hard. It takes real effort and diligence.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by g-b-r on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:42AM (#50508316)
It's unfortunate that you had to pay actual money and effort, but there was also actual money and effort involved in the projects on which the LLM output is based.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by tim-projects on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:01PM (#50508502)
When a carpenter crafts a chair, the tree first had to make effort to generate the wood.

Because chairs are in effect an open source design, does that mean carpenters shouldn't get paid?

Its nonsensical.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by g-b-r on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:13PM (#50508621)
Yes, what you wrote is definitely nonsensical.

Chairs can be covered by design protection.

And however hard a carpenter might work on a chair, if he copies a protected design he can't sell the chair.

However much work you might add on top of other people's copyrighted code, you don't get to sell it and use it however you want if you don't have the permission of the original authors.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by lelanthran on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:39PM (#50509446)
> However much work you might add on top of other people's copyrighted code, you don't get to sell it and use it however you want if you don't have the permission of the original authors.

It gets even more hilarious when you realise that the GP (tim) does not consider that, if you make the output of AI that was trained on copyrighted material legal to re-copyright, then it applies to him as well - all that hard work he did can be used chucked into an LLM either as context, or via LoRA, or even via simple explorative usage via tool calls, and then regenerated from that LLM, taking away whatever copyright the product had by generating a competing clone.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50509402

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by dmitrygr on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:15PM (#50508644)
The difference between the input to the carpenter and the output of the carpenter is significantly greater than the input from you to the LLM, and the output of LLM. Majority of the alterations to the wood by the carpenter produced the chair. The words you typed into an LLM are less than 0.000000001% of the total inputs that it took to create its output (because training data counts, and it’s a lot bigger than anything you may have typed)
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by or1gaminal on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:27PM (#50508762)
Absolutely. There is so much variability in the code that can be generated for a particular purpose. I do hundreds of iterations before my LLM-generated code reaches the desired shape. The built harness, the written AGENTS.md and the iterations affects what is written greatly.

And at least of the level of feeling the answer is that it is my code.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by ozozozd on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:31PM (#50508811)
It also takes effort to copy something, right? Say I made a copy of a book by hand, does my effort make it any less of a copy?

Say I am stealing stuff that’s really heavy, can I demand I earned it because it was a lot of effort?

I am not trying to be facetious. I also question property rights because someone overpowered someone else to make that property theirs at some point in time. Whose effort is earned, and whose is robbery?

As far as I can tell we picked an arbitrary time after which all forced acquisition is considered robbery.

That being said, open source is for everyone to benefit. Violating an open source license is sort of a crime against everyone, not just the creator.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by lelanthran on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:35PM (#50509402)
> I have some projects I've been working on over a year. Sitting down working making design decisions. Research. Using ai doesn't mean I did no work. It doesn't matter if the ai was trained. I still did work.

> I don't understand this view point. Using ai and making high quality stuff is not pushing a button. Its hard. It takes real effort and diligence. And you have to pay actual money out of pocket to deliver it.

You seem to believe that because you put months of work into this, you should have rights over the result, right?

But once you release, anyone can spend a few dozens of dollars and replicate it. Do they get the same rights over the clone that you got over your product, even though you potentially spent months coming up with it and they cloned it in a day?

There's really only two answers to this - either you agree that they should get the same rights over the clone that you got over your product, or you don't agree that they should have the same rights over their clone that you have over your product.

In either case, you are not better off:

1. If they get the same rights over the clone that you get on your product, you can't really stop people cloning your stuff, adding a feature or two, removing another feature or two, and then release something better than you for 1/10th of the cost of production.

2. If they don't get the same rights as you did because they used your product as training material for a clone, then wtf do you get any rights at all, after using millions of other people's products as training material?

I don't see any scenario where there is an outcome beneficial to you. Do you?

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by _aavaa_ on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:35PM (#50509914)
This is a false dichotomy. In this example the person you’re replying to isn’t wholesale copying someone’s work.
Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by lelanthran on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:45PM (#50510001)
> This is a false dichotomy. In this example the person you’re replying to isn’t wholesale copying someone’s work.

So? I said "clone", but clarified that features may be added to the clone to make a better product.

Taking his product $FOO, adding it to my training set/context/RAG/LORA and/or tool call to explore his product in detail before I tell my LLM to produce $FOO+1 is exactly the same thing that he did.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by _aavaa_ on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:54PM (#50513086)
> $FOO+1 is exactly the same thing that he did.

No it isn’t. That’s an assumption you made in order to for your point. It is not what they said they did.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by lelanthran on Monday November 16, 2026 @01:20AM (#50514622)
> No it isn’t. That’s an assumption you made in order to force your false dichotomy. It is not what they said they did.

There is no practical difference to person A getting a product by prompting an LLM (what GP did) and person B getting a product by prompting an LLM.

What do you see them doing different? After all, any product they produce is fair game to use for anyone else wanting to train an LLM; the AI companies have already legitimised that, and their own software products are getting cloned en-masse without them being able to do anything about it.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by bartnp on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:37PM (#50509931)
3. Others are free to use the produced material as educational/training material if they can gain access to the code to then use it for their inspiration. But they are not allowed to outright duplicate it.

This seems the obvious answer? No? The exact clone at 1/10 the cost is just really unlikely imo, especially if it's closed source. And with open source this was already a problem anyway, you could always fork, but hey, turns out most people just stick to the original anyway

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by lelanthran on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:50PM (#50510051)
> No? The exact clone at 1/10 the cost is just really unlikely imo, especially if it's closed source.

The availability of the source is irrelevant; I posed this question with the understanding that I could simply add your product, whether closed or not, to my LLM, and get it to produce a better product without all that pesky effort and token usage you used.

Release your product. See how quickly it gets "cloned". i.e. copied and reproduced without anyone needing the source code.

All that effort of yours... just to result in someone else producing the same product in a different language, but with all your product decisions already baked in for nowhere near what it cost you.

> And with open source this was already a problem anyway, you could always fork

Sure, and people famously did so, but they could not clone original closed-source products without a lot of effort, often taking months to years. Now, the result of you spending years on perfecting a product means that a clone can arise in a matter of days.

Re:All AI-generated code should be Open Source by xcf_seetan on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:22PM (#50509797)
What if I am creating something that does not exists yet using AI? So i did the research, layout the architecture, decide on the implementation details, write the documentation and the rules AI has to use to create the software, because I am only one person and I can't physically write all that code on my own on a timely basis (it would take me years to write all that code, test it and debug it until i am satisfied)? I am creating something new, not copying anything, so where I stand? Can i publish my code, say with MIT licensing, and retain the copyright?