Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video]
by The_President on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:50PM
(#50509532)
Big fan of KDE, but little issues like the direction taken in regards to depricating ksysguard ("speghetti code") in favor of the slow plasma-systemmonitor application, all while the bluetooth implementation is half baked and krunner is laggy, is disappointing. One of the best daily desktop environments but with a history of minor priority issues.
Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video]
by account42 on Monday November 16, 2026 @09:25AM
(#50517925)
Yeah, its a shame how some people feel the need to take over existing OSS projects to enforce their views on the established userbase rathern than gaining users for their way of doing things by convincing them that it is actually better.
I don't think this works well. For instance, KDE back in 2006 or 2007, give or take, was very different to KDE in 2026. Not only because older people tend to retire (or die), and younger people follow up, but also because of policy changes and different people pushing through with their ideas. Back in 2006, you would not be able to find someone like Nate who wants to push a donation-daemon into KDE. Fast forward and suddenly you have that. You also have people wanting to add a dependency on systemd (David Edmundson) - lo and behold, that is suddenly happening. I could bring more examples, but I feel that it is unfair to claim xyz at this point in time, is KDE or how KDE always used to be. That's simply not the case. It is no the case with GNOME either; see why mate-desktop was forked when people did not want to transition into a smartphone-centric UI (though there is no real way around that with GTK5 eventually, since it will be wayland-locked-down only).
So these videos are just happy-go-lucky. That's IMO very bad.
I'd much prefer a style such as in the old movie manufacturing consent. Now, the movie also had various issues and is also quite outdated now, but at the least you'd have a SLIGHTLY more balanced view rather than just a promo-video, which this video is ultimately about.
Edit: mongol shared a somewhat similar criticism; not about the above mentioned content, but with regards to KDE 4 and the promo-video totally ignoring that fact. Well, this is a sunshine-video. It has no real substance indeed so I concur with mongol on that part.
I also agree with iberator, though I was never that much a DE user per se. I did use KDE 3.x, naturally 4.x was a dead end, but already before that I transitioned into fluxbox. From a workflow-centric approach, I found fluxbox to be so much more productive than KDE. I would use KDE konsole on fluxbox, though, as it is a great terminal. okular is also ok-ish, though I found evince to be snappier and faster, so I use that for .pdf files usually (okular is more feature-rich though). Most other KDE programs I don't really need; I do most actions via KDE konsole and scripts.