News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by tristanj on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:02AM (#50507009)
The space shuttle program was doomed from the start because it was designed as a manned vehicle. Unlike Starship, it couldn't fly unmanned.

Shuttle had to fly humans, and had to maintain its human-rated spaceflight safety rating. This meant that any design change or modification had to be tested extensively to ensure it didn't kill the crew. This took multiple design iterations, took a long time, and was not cheap.

After the initial design of the ship, it made the program very risk averse. Changing anything required a lot of testing, so it was easier to not change it. Shuttle got stuck because it became too difficult and expensive to iterate; Congress did not give NASA enough funds to overcome this, so the project stagnated.

For Starship, it flies without humans so it can rapidly iterate and evolve. SpaceX can make radical design changes, perform minimal testing, then put these changes on the next flight and see what happens. Sometimes it fails catastrophically (which is the main reason Starship keeps blowing up). They can also push the ship close to failure limits, and see how the ship performs, without worrying about humans on board. This allowed rapid iteration and faster evolution of the vehicle.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by pfdietz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @09:45AM (#50507291)
Human rating was more of a PR issue. The value of the human lives on the orbiter was much less than the value of the orbiter itself. So the cost of an accident would not have been significantly reduced by making it unmanned.

Shuttle's real problem was it was just an uneconomical design. It was foolish to expect government and its cost-plus contractors to be able to optimize for cost.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by xp84 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:49AM (#50507820)
I see your point financially, however you’re just undervaluing the cost of highly-public deaths then. If a couple missions in a row for any manned program resulted in astronauts being incinerated, it costs the full future value of whole program, because astronauts won’t go on it anymore and the public will also demand its end.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by pfdietz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:02AM (#50507959)
Right, that's a PR issue. It's ultimately because the space program is not actually producing much of tangible value, but rather a perception of value. A program that is producing airy PR is vulnerable to bad PR.

The government has no problem with programs producing tangible value that also cost lives. Consider the military, police, search and rescue, and really any activity where people do anything with nonzero risk. The lives lost are part of the cost.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by true_religion on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:13PM (#50509222)
[delayed]
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by xp84 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:52PM (#50509543)
One death isn't too many. It's a matter of too high a probability of general random catastrophe.

Example: Astronaut Tim goes on an EVA to perform an emergency repair after a micrometeorite damaged the space station. A malfunction of his space suit kills him. Everyone agrees that Tim died a hero doing a high-risk activity that needed to be done, and almost no one would say it means we can't do spacewalks or can't send astronauts to space anymore.

Compare to Challenger or Columbia: The whole crew dies randomly on the way up or down during a routine mission. A program which became known for having like, a 10% chance of that happening would be horrifying (in my opinion).

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by pfdietz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:42PM (#50510498)
If the Shuttle had been cheap they would have tolerated the losses, refined the design, built more, and kept on chugging.

But Shuttle was an economic as well as a safety fiasco. So there was no good motivation to keep using it.

The biggest tragedy of the Shuttle program was the 12 figure cumulative budget it consumed, equivalent to many thousands of lives.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by RhodesianHunter on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:51AM (#50507836)
I sure hope you never work on anything where human lives are in the balance.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by pfdietz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:04AM (#50507974)
I sure hope you're never involved in any policy decisions, as you are clearly not able to make them rationally.

Assigning a finite value to human lives (in the US, it's around $12M) is absolutely essential to evaluating policy tradeoffs.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by PKop on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:08AM (#50508005)
> the cost of an accident would not have been significantly reduced by making it unmanned

> people are unrealistic about the value of human lives

Which one is it?

Given 2 is true and extreme, politics dominates all, and anyone acting like you would have been thrown out of political power as fast as possible. So no, "the cost of" does not pertain only to materiel and technical development, etc.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by pfdietz on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:00PM (#50510134)
Like people are thrown out of political power because of military training accidents? (This is about 400 deaths/year in the US.)

No, those are just par for the course, a necessary cost for a military that can deliver its intended function.

Manned space has the problem it was set up as theater, not to deliver value independent of the theatrics.

If a space program costs billions of dollars a year, but cannot tolerate any deaths, it should just be abandoned, since it clearly isn't delivering enough value to justify those billions of dollars.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by burnerRhodov3 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:55AM (#50508440)
Oh... you just met a big space shuttle nerd.

This is not true... The shuttle mission was highly automated. Launch, orbit, reentry was all automated. They only needed human pilots to land on the runway because their algo's weren't good enough. Which, again, was one of many design failures of the shuttle. Having humans on board only slightly increased the chance of success according to nasa. other failures were their ablative heat shield ontop of the ceramica, the carbon-on-carbon plating around the aluminum housing, using aluminum as the body and fins instead of steel, AND DROPPING THEIR BOOSTERS IN THE FUCKING OCEAN.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by jimmydorry on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:16PM (#50508657)
>AND DROPPING THEIR BOOSTERS IN THE FUCKING OCEAN

As opposed to dropping them in the desert or a town? The risk appetite was not there at all to figure out safe capture of the boosters. And if they had the allowance to tackle that problem, it would have been better focussed on improving the shuttle itself, fixing the problems GP has outlined.

Of all the issues, "dropping their boosters in the fucking ocean" probably doesn't even make top 10.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by burnerRhodov3 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:20PM (#50508702)
i'm talking about recovery. They couldn't because they caught it with parachutes.

Again, stage zero is a huge enegineering challange and issue that Nasa didn't even attempt to solve because it was too hard.

Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by azernik on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:38PM (#50508880)
There was no way to Shuttle to land except on a runway. So yes, it did require human pilots.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by rozab on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:57PM (#50509056)
Buran proved there was no technical obstacle to uncrewed runway landing, the US could have achieved it a few years earlier if it was a priority. The Buran landing system was more complex than you might expect, and proved to be pretty adaptable in its only orbital flight.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by burnerRhodov3 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:03PM (#50509110)
no, you missed what i said. Having humans only slightly improved the odds of mission success... Meaning they did have algorithms to autonomously land on a runway.. They chose not to.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by tekla on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:33PM (#50511034)
NASA chose not to because of several reasons, but the pilots really really wanted to be able to control the orbiter (probably because many were test pilots and liked the adrenaline). After Columbia, the orbiter was retrofitted to fly itself to the ground just fine.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by burnerRhodov3 on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:05PM (#50521527)
but OP used that as the whole reason it failed... They could have, if they wanted, land it without people. Thus, the "reason" it failed is untrue.
Re:SpaceX Catches the Starship to end Flight 15 by voidUpdate on Monday November 16, 2026 @04:33AM (#50515706)
I've heard that the only reason it needed humans on board was to lower the landing gear, which was such a critical part of landing that a computer wasn't trusted to lower them at the right time, which seems a bit weird given that a computer could be trusted to do everything else