If you think demand will break down before you can get a return on your investemtn, you should not build.
If you think of a different aspect of "the AI bububle popping", where demand for RAM does not significantly decrease, that's fine of course. But RAM demand by AI going down massively seems to be a major part of what a lot of people imagine when they talk about the bubble going away.
Even if we got back to pre-AI bubble, hell, especially if we got back to pre-ai bubble pricing, we'd see a lot of push for local AI and 32 GB+ GPUs/128GB+ SOC systems
I put up as an example and prefaced it with me not knowing enough about the market and tech. I have not done the calculations, because I have no access to any of the relevant numbers, do not have a relevant model of the market dynamics I would expect, and do not have to suffer the losses if it doesn't play out.
It is great that you have more knowledge to be able to confidently state those things, however, I have to say I have no reason to actually believe you do.
A bubble means something is overvalued. The stock prices will go down if the bubble pops, but not the demand.
I don't think your very narrow definition of a bubble is shared with everyone else, nor that over valuing an investment doesn't lead to inflated demand (and the he investments drying up leading to reduced demand because companies sometimes need money to pay for the demand they create).
Yahoo kind of went away, but Google replaced them. I really don't understand why people would think that anything would change even if all the known AI companies went under tomorrow. We are still going to use AI more and more and we are still needing more and more hardware for that. Doesn't matter which company it is that is involved in all that.
> Not long term of course
Building more fabs is very much a long term thing, though.
Neither does its being here to stay does not mean it is good or desirable.
In any case "It is here to stay." does not resemble a falsifiable claim. If you were wrong how could you tell?
Passenger rail versus freight rail also demonstrates how the railroad bubble and aftermath ended up proving that not every use of rail is inherently profitable. In the long term, passenger rail is rarely profitable and almost always has to be subsidized by the state in some way with only a handful of exceptions.
Nearly everything could have a non-colluding explanation depending on the tech and market. (for example I would be skeptical to build up extremly expensive production if i follow the widespread belief that Ai is a huge bubble)
However, collusion is not magically out of the question with previous instances and some unexplained indicators. (which imo is what this dismissal means)