News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by no-name-here on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:45AM (#50504601)
> extortion

What do you think Google is extorting from the publishers of insecure software - reduced security vulnerabilities? Or what is it that you think Google is actually after by doing this?

> guise of security

What do you think is the real motivation if not security?

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:29AM (#50504825)
Google is extorting free fixes for software Google depends on, instead of paying for them to be fixed.

As seen by the infamous FFMPEG incident: https://thenewstack.io/ffmpeg-to-google-fund-us-or-stop-send...

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by justin_oaks on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:09AM (#50505291)
I read the linked article and can't find anything involving extortion; just that one person associated with the FFMPEG didnt like the flood of vulnerability reports.

In fact, the article cites one of the FFMPEG maintainers as being grateful for the vulnerability reports.

Did I miss something?

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:31AM (#50505773)
Yes. You are missing the wider interpretation of the word extortion that includes obtaining benefit by coercion. Presumably you are only including extortion by use of blatantly illegal means in your definition. However, you don't need to threaten using illegal means to be extorting and/or blackmailing someone. You can be blackmailing someone by threatening to sue them in court, for example.

Google is extorting benefit, specifically fixes to software it heavily depends on for its multi billion dollar business, by coercion, specifically by actively threatening the project with reputational damage in 90 days if certain action is not taken, even if the action is not in the vendors best interest.

As a thought experiment, imagine if Google was reporting this to the project, but _without_ the 90 day limit. The one that the original article describes going down to 60 then 30 days. Yes, you might first think "that will cause the projects to never fix bugs" which might be true for some projects, but you do realize how legally that would completely change the dynamic between Google and the project and remove the entire extortion part from the picture? Or indeed, if they simply published it without any notice at all.

Whether or not other people also happen to benefit is related, but it doesn't remove the fact that Google also benefits.

Or if you would like a more vivid picture:

If the Mob forces you to give them a room in your hotel for illegal poker tournaments and then gives you tips on how to make the windows safer so that bricks can't fly through them, it does improve safety for all your clients but it's still extortion.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by Diagon on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:45PM (#50511679)
As someone coming from the outside, it's astounding to me how oblivious so many in this discussion are to the obvious, ie. the question of power. Flip through a few texts on psychoanalysis, and you'll find this called "attacks on linking," always a from of motivated behavior.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by fc417fc802 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @04:21AM (#50505349)
If google stops sending ffmpeg vulnerability reports the software will still be vulnerable but neither the maintainers nor the end users will be aware of it. As someone who makes use of ffmpeg I want google to continue sending such reports. If I'm running vulnerable software I very much want to know about it.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:10AM (#50505634)
You frequently transcode 40 year old Lucas Arts SCUMM VM videos?

I would prefer ffmpeg team to have the time to focus on slightly newer stuff, as a user myself.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by no-name-here on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:15AM (#50505663)
Does Google require ffmpeg to fix vulns? Per the GP commenter's point, isn't this just about whether people are eventually made aware of known vulns?
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by fc417fc802 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:26AM (#50505742)
Precisely. If it isn't worth fixing then don't fix it. As the end user I can then make an informed decision. If nothing else I'll know to thoroughly sandbox certain workloads if an unpatched CVE is applicable.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @05:35AM (#50505793)
They require ffmpeg to respond in a Google controlled timeline.

Just because the response can be "No", it doesn't mean Google didn't require _something_ from ffmpeg.

If they wanted to, they could also have "close to bug when fixed and we will only then notify the public", or they could have 0-day and just publish without notice.

But because they _actively choose_ 90 (60, 30) day windows, they _do_ require something from the projects that they report on.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:20AM (#50506065)
> Just because the response can be "No", it doesn't mean Google didn't require _something_ from ffmpeg.

It requires zero things from ffmpeg. As it is today, they privately contact them with info about the vulnerability and also informs them that in 90 days the whole world will know about the vulnerability too.

ffmpeg ca either fix it if it wants or be "cool story bro, yolo".

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @06:34AM (#50506139)
So, what if the project they are reporting to has a vulnerability disclosure project with 180 days notice?
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by akerl_ on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:45AM (#50506907)
Project Zero doesn’t care.

Why would a project get to tell somebody who found a vuln when they can talk about it to the public?

Imagine you go to a restaurant and see an issue with the food. You tell the restaurant “hey I’m writing a review of this. I’m going to publish it in a month; if you want to include any response before that time I’ll include it in my review”.

It would be nuts for the restaurant to say “actually we require you wait 180 days to publish”.

You can also take a look at how essentially all investigative reporting works, where a reporter asks the subject for comment before publishing.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by FabCH on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:43PM (#50509477)
You might be surprised to learn that actually is illegal in some countries.

Famously, leaving reviews on TripAdvisor in Germany can get you sued.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by akerl_ on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:07PM (#50509678)
You can be sued for anything.

I did some light searching here and the examples appear to match what I’d expect: you can be liable if you lie about facts, but if you’re sharing your opinions or accurately relating what happened, you’re fine.

Can you provide some examples for your claim?

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by fc417fc802 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:20PM (#50509783)
Even if he managed to provide examples it would merely be demonstrating a restriction on the individual to openly speak his mind. Hardly something to celebrate.

Similarly, if there were a jurisdiction somewhere in the world where vulnerability research was criminalized I don't think that would be relevant to the conversation we're having here. AFAIK project zero is subject only to US law.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by akerl_ on Sunday November 15, 2026 @03:39PM (#50510462)
Project Zero is part of Google/Alphabet, which operates globally and has a legal presence in many countries. I can’t speak to where individuals on Project Zero are based.

If they provided evidence of their claim, I would have learned something new and it would be potentially interesting to the discussion about the risks of making public factual disclosures in places other than the US. It’s not a matter of whether or not it would be something to celebrate.

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by ExoticPearTree on Sunday November 15, 2026 @11:20PM (#50513987)
You are missing something: the simple fact that Google operates in many countries does not make it liable in those countries for what other Business Units inside it do.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by fc417fc802 on Monday November 16, 2026 @02:07AM (#50514882)
Well TBF that is entirely dependent on how large their market is in that country and on how many assets they have there that could realistically be seized by the authorities. But in practice it does seem difficult to imagine that sort of stuff being relevant to project zero.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by akerl_ on Monday November 16, 2026 @11:53AM (#50519738)
What you’re calling a simple fact here isn’t really either.

Countries attempt, with varying levels of success, to regulate international entities based on activity they conduct elsewhere in the world all the time.

And as an aside, it’s not clear that Project Zero is actually purely US-based: https://www.google.com/about/careers/applications/jobs/resul...

Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by marshray on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:30PM (#50509371)
The problem is that the attacker gets to choose the codec that your device runs.
Re:Project Zero will disclose vulnerabilities 90 days after ... by Devasta on Sunday November 15, 2026 @08:41AM (#50506877)
> What do you think is the real motivation if not security?

For a lot of security people its collecting scout badges.