News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by k0morebi on Saturday November 14, 2026 @07:55PM (#50502831)
Not speaking about the possible knowledge of smuggling in contravention of law, marital infidelity, and possibility getting mixed up with an intelligence agent, but I don't see the circular financing thing as a problem. Maybe I'm misinformed.

But weren't they were investing money in companies to help them grow and in turn buy more of their product. Of course Nvidia wants to stimulate demand of their product. I don't think this was nefarious. There is no free lunch, the risk of them never getting that money back is real with a lot of these pie in the sky AI companies. How is this anticompetitive? It's all of these SPVs that meta, google, and others are using that I think needs to be investigated and punished by wall street.

If you think that's wrong, USE YOUR WORDS, I'm open to reason. Down voting with no response or making jeers is not effective communication.

Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by lizknope on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:00PM (#50502865)
The other thread from yesterday on this has far more discussion and answers

You can read the WSJ article

https://archive.is/20261113091227/https://www.wsj.com/tech/j...

And my comment in the other thread

It may not be illegal but if you are investing in AI companies you need to think about whether the demand for AI chips is real or artificial and being manipulated by Nvidia.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50493251#50496483

> Then he went on to describe the situation the company was in. Major cloud providers were running away from Nvidia, making plans to use alternative chips and lessen their reliance on the firm. Even worse, Huang said, the vast supply of chip wafers and memory Nvidia had committed to buying were coming at him like an “avalanche.”

Jensen's son-in-law was making these vendor financed deals and Kress the CFO now interim CEO was against them.

Large customers like Nvidia and Apple want billions of chips. TSMC can't just ramp up and down instantly. It takes 3+ years and $30 billion to build a modern fab. So TSMC has contracts where you are commiting to buy the wafers for years in advance.

I've worked for multiple fabless chip companies that use TSMC to manufacture. Amazon, Google, Microsoft, and the other big hyperscalers are making their own AI chips to move away from Nvidia. The startups like OpenAI are doing the same so the real demand for Nvidia chips is dropping. But Nvidia can't easily get out of the contracts with TSMC to manufacture and buy the chips. They would probably have multi billion penalties that would show up on their financial statements.

Some people think Nvidia is acting as a VC fund for AI startups but my view is that Jensen freaked out about the dropping demand for Nvidia chips. So he is funding these startups with circular finance deals to buy the Nvidia chips that he can't sell to the hyperscalers anymore.

Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by bourbonproof on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:17PM (#50502979)
interesting, so this looks like a booking trick: you see the demand collapsing, and looking into penalties from TSMC that show up in statements making the demand crystal obvious to anyone, and you think you might just turn this penalties into "investments" into ai companies that then buy these chips. no TSMC penalty, no statement visible that shows low demand. Problem solved. Well played.
Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by mondrian on Saturday November 14, 2026 @11:04PM (#50503906)
Also to the companies buying the chips it looks like exchanging a small fraction of stock shares for a significant bump in market cap + free pile of chips.
Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by pokot0 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:39PM (#50503124)
Where do these hyperscalers plan to build these chips? The bottleneck seems to be TSMC and if you have a deal to secure their output for the next couple of years you should be happy… I can understand NVDA losing their technological competitive advantage but it’s harder to see a general slowdown of demand for computing.
Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by lizknope on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:50PM (#50503198)
The hyperscalers have already been building chips at TSMC for years now. Look at Amazon Graviton, Trainium, Google Axion and their TPU, and Microsoft Maia. You can use them right now or last year.

Some of them are looking at Intel and Samsung but that is usually using them as a negotiating tactic to get better pricing with TSMC.

Nvidia may or not not be technically better. The hyperscalers want independence from Nvidia.

Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by ksec on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:50PM (#50503197)
>So he is funding these startups with circular finance deals to buy the Nvidia chips that he can't sell to the hyperscalers anymore.

Hyperscalers are building their chip doesn't mean they are not buying Nvidia GPU. The two can coexist. Microsoft could train their model without CUDA but Azure will still need to rent out GPU for their customers as demand is so high.

And considering the demand is so high, capacity planning from TSMC is what makes or breaks the industry. All Hyperscaler combined does not hold as much volume in the capacity planing than Nvidia.

Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by nl on Sunday November 15, 2026 @12:35AM (#50504295)
> Amazon, Google, Microsoft, and the other big hyperscalers are making their own AI chips to move away from Nvidia. The startups like OpenAI are doing the same

This is true

> so the real demand for Nvidia chips is dropping.

This isn't true.

The hyperscalers are still buying as many Nvidia chips as they can. They are limited by supply, not demand.

Nvidia is carefully making sure they have as many buyers as possible. This is excellent business strategy.

There is a reasonable debate on to what level they should do vendor financing for this. But the general idea of trying to make sure they have as many buyers as possible is very sensible.

Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by InsidiousWombat on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:05PM (#50502893)
It's not a problem if the financed companies turn a profit.

It's gonna be pretty huge problem if they don't.

> How is this anticompetitive?

By sheer fact the circular financing deals makes them buy NVIDIA and not competition, it's making NVIDIA the preferable product.

If not for the financing, the same companies would often be looking for cheapest way to get the compute.

> It's all of these SPVs that meta, google, and others are using that I think needs to be investigated and punished by wall street.

that's whataboutism. Both are problem

Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by chrisjharris on Saturday November 14, 2026 @09:01PM (#50503258)
I don't see the issue either. You could argue that it's not the wisest idea, but that's NVIDIA's call to make. I don't think it's inherently anti-competitive; or at least only in the sense that making a better product is anti-competitive. You're giving your customers what they want.
Re:Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular... by roenxi on Saturday November 14, 2026 @10:22PM (#50503679)
[delayed]