Put another way, the type of person who is naturally “boring” and not very reactive probably won’t get themselves tangled with the kind of person that needs to be “grey rocked”. If you are always a gray rock, then you are not an easy target for a manipulator.
Maybe it is defensive but it can also be aggressive. For situations where time is on their side, it can really just be a means of handling the situation - there is no reason to think it is only a defence against aggressors. It is ultimately just a manipulation technique.
Perhaps it's a stretch, but I think the policy that Google has in place, where they are notoriously hard to get a response from, is an example of aggressive grey rocking. They have no interest in hearing your possibly justified complaint - if they make it impossible for you to speak, you have no ability to sell redress. Endless complaint procedures are the same thing. Being put on hold for hours also.
It is unhealthy simply because it's a rebranded form of passive aggression. The real problem is not yet having figured out why someone like that can get under your skin in the first place.
The exact same situations that can bubble up unhealthy amounts of negative emotion in younger people don't do that in older people. Older people have already been there and done that. They fully understand the behavior and instead of anger or retaliation they usually feel pity or nothing at all. Which mind do you think is healthier?
In other words, there's no escaping life's lessons. Your best bet is to minimize the unavoidable consequences and stay out of trouble. For sure, a big part of that is cutting out bullshit like Esquire.
That's the exact definition of "grey rocking." It's a harm minimization technique taught to victims of narcissists who are unable to immediately get away from the narcissist. Examples would be people who must stay in contact because of kids, or someone planning an escape over the course of weeks/months.
I know someone personally in the latter category. "Grey rocking" for the week prior was indeed "their best bet" and definitely not "woo woo."
It's nonsense.
But he's got a point. Lots of time, we do have a choice. This is especially true online. We know someone is saying/doing crazy things just to get attention, but we still engage, especially when it comes to topics like politics and religion. At that point, I suppose it is more of our fault.
That said, this is unlikely to fully work with colleagues, family, friends. So maybe the always part is not true?
This is all easy in theory, but the difficulty comes in having the discipline to practice...
Median people, who have good family relationships by what I would superficially view to be the default, don't understand how much harder the hardships are, and sometimes ask why I don't cut family off. Well, if I cut them off, now I don't have a family, which is a suboptimal outcome. (It may be the best outcome, and understanding that this might happen made things easier; thankfully that's not how it went.)
Anyway, the short answer is both can be good.
Long-term, it can be hard to sustain, and maybe a bit unhealthy – it becomes a form of self-betrayal, where you repeatedly suppress genuine negative feelings about dealing with someone difficult. These feelings are there for a reason, even if expressing them with the person triggering them would be counterproductive.
Also, in more extreme cases, the sort of people who are prone to creating drama and conflict pick up on the technique and make it into a battle of wills – who will break and give up first. And they may be a lot better at it than you are, because for them it is a central feature of their personality, and for you it's just a tactic for immediate relief.