News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by mpol on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:18PM (#50499353)
Really great documentary, very much suggested to watch it.

I had no idea Gnome was started without ever talking to the Qt and KDE people. If there was discussion and a solution about the license, the present would be very different I assume. Still, there would be many WMs and DE's, but KDE would be somewhat of a centerpoint.

Also, Aaron Seigo took the criticism of KDE 4 quite hard I would guess. It might be why he is not involved in the project anymore.

Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by einpoklum on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:33PM (#50500017)
> the present would be very different I assume.

I frankly doubt it. GNOME has pushed many problematic choices which KDE hasn't, or at least hadn't initially. From the anti-usability bent of the UI (few buttons, monochrome over color, non-configurability), to the dependence on systemd, to dropping X in favor of Wayland etc. And this is in part motivated IMHO by the organizational backing for GNOME which is different than KDE.

Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by ahartmetz on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:37PM (#50500578)
Disclaimer: I'm a KDE developer though not super active.

Regarding paid developers, it used to be a few people working for Suse on KDE vs a lot of people working for Red Hat on Gnome. That's not all there is to it because team Gnome also had to maintain GTK and team KDE didn't have to maintain Qt. Gnome had the advantage of having people paid to work on low-level services such as libxml, libdbus and such. AFAIK, today no desktop has many developers paid by distros. You can see it for example on GTK being maintained by like one guy.

Reportedly, external people and companies find KDE is easier to work with than Gnome, and that probably at least played into Valve selecting KDE. Valve's support led to (among other things) KDE having a really really good compositor / window manager. Highly reliable multi-screen support, fractional scaling, high dynamic range, variable refresh rate, frame scheduling for minimum latency (hell yeah), dimming with and without backlight control... a lot of good stuff.

Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by Conan_Kudo on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:22PM (#50503019)
> Regarding paid developers, it used to be a few people working for Suse on KDE vs a lot of people working for Red Hat on Gnome.

There was also Novell/Ximian and Sun Microsystems too. And later on, Canonical did too. All of those companies invested heavily in GNOME alongside Red Hat in the early 2000s.

Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by ankurdhama on Sunday November 15, 2026 @10:06PM (#50513548)
But Valve uses their own compositor i.e gamescope for the game mode UI that is the default UI on Steam deck. AFAIK KDE software is only used for desktop mode which is not the main UI of steam deck and more of tool for advance users.
Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by WD-42 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @03:26PM (#50500477)
I’m not sure if you grasp how bad the license situation was. Debian wasn’t even able to ship KDE, like at all. Something had to be done, well beyond “just have a conversation”.
Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by mpol on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:29PM (#50501052)
Well, you need to start with a conversation to find a solution together.

I can understand it to start your own thing, but not even starting a discussion seems a bit immature.

Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by WD-42 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @04:43PM (#50501220)
Trust me, there were plenty of discussions, and flames, and all kinds of nonsense. QT was the only game in town, so they thought they could use that as leverage on the license issue. Thus, GTK.
Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by F3nd0 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @05:22PM (#50501586)
Concurrent to GTK, there were also Harmony and GNUstep, right?
Re:KDE: The Documentary on Free Software [video] by noisy_boy on Sunday November 15, 2026 @01:32PM (#50509387)
> Also, Aaron Seigo took the criticism of KDE 4 quite hard I would guess. It might be why he is not involved in the project anymore.

Isn't he the one who built the Plasma foundations that are still holding up the desktop pretty well? Not sure if he is not involved but he is pretty much vindicated by now.