News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by mindwok on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:28PM (#50493061)
Feels like drones and rockets have created a similar dynamic to mutually assured destruction, except for much smaller actors with far fewer resources. It's not hard to imagine a future where e.g. Taiwan is just armed with so many cheap drones and rockets that for even a great power like China the guarantee of enormous economic damage at home is just not worth it.
Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by illwrks on Friday November 13, 2026 @09:33PM (#50493111)
Surely that just means tactics change? The attacking force needs to coordinate tightly to block airwaves and have total control as quickly as possible before any meaningful counter measure can be attempted - meaning more drone swarms, more boots on the ground and more direct attack and control of comms channels.

It also means that any potential victim probably needs to account for that scenario and be ready to retaliate at a moments notice.

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by glenstein on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:03PM (#50493331)
I don't disagree with the principle necessarily, but I think it goes too far to think there's always just some tactical adjustment you can make that wholly neutralizes every next emerging combat technology.

Seems like lasers that fry drones en masse will become more important, and the scale and automation at which drones can be produced will be a BFD. But those are specific inputs that impact in specific ways, and those nuts and bolts need to be the target of analysis. That work can't be replaced by assuming eternal strategic equilibrium regardless of tech.

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by colechristensen on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:40PM (#50493594)
>Seems like lasers that fry drones en masse will become more important

Eh you don't need lasers, bullets are fine. You just can't have air defense these days that only relies on individual shots costing tens of thousands to tens of millions of dollars each.

What's funny to me is that it's not unreasonable that a nontrivial amount of future air war is going to look like Top Gun dogfighting on the scale of childrens' toys.

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by colechristensen on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:12PM (#50493389)
Current air defense is lagging behind and was tailored to targets that were high, fast, few, and expensive.

New air defense tactics need to include mitigations for targets that fly low, are very cheap, and numerous.

In the end I think the cheap drone advantage will be entirely accounted for but it will take time and real world experience to figure out what works.

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by nradov on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:29PM (#50493512)
Tactics will change but not all communication channels can be blocked. Some fraction of the drones used by Russia and Ukraine are now controlled using fiber optic cables. Those are relatively slow, have a maximum range of about 40 km, and can't be used over water. But they're immune to jamming and very effective against ground targets. Within line of sight, tight beam spread spectrum radio signals are also very difficult to jam.

As for putting more boots on the ground, geography and weather make it tough to put a large amphibious force ashore in Taiwan. There are only a few harbors or beaches where it could even be attempted.

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by ric2b on Saturday November 14, 2026 @01:15PM (#50499327)
How do you get boots on the ground quickly enough without being detected while being large enough to take over all the drone storage locations?
Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by himata4113 on Friday November 13, 2026 @10:00PM (#50493306)
china can turn taiwan into rubble with conventional resources, there is a rather large body of water seperating the two as well which allows for very easy defense compared to something like ukraine.
Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by bean469 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:48PM (#50510035)
Turning Taiwan into rubble would likely be a bad idea if they want to take over the chip manufacturing facilities
Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by maxglute on Friday November 13, 2026 @11:54PM (#50494079)
>except for much smaller actors

That's what TW is relative to PRC. The real issue is quantity and quality gap with dash of geography, mass subsonic drone like Ukraine + Iran are basically 100% interceptable with modern interceptors. Still high double digit percentages for shit tier ballistics (i.e. Iran). Penetration really only issue with depletion, i.e. PRC can build more interceptors than TW can build drones. The secondary consideration of geography, TW vs PRC and Iran vs Israel has very narrow corridors and intercepts can be concentrated. UKR vs RU has a large front, too much gaps to cover over land (sensors over water works much better - less clutter).

The real threat is HIGH end conventional rocketry, i.e. PRC/US hypersonics which modern missile defense very unreliable (technical/economic) against. This less issue for PRC vs TW since frankly every inch of TW is covered and reachable within 4-5m of PRC rocketry which is below typical TEL launch cycles - small close adversaries easy to defang if there's enough munitions to suppress... even at larger scale US vs Iran, US managed to lock down Iranian fires as long as there was coverage.

The corollary to high end conventional rocketry is they are basically hemispherical+ range. So everything that is happening to RU oil infra... can happen to US oil infra... or basically any above ground infra with PRC conventional global strike, i.e. PRC's deterrence/answer to Malacca energy blockade is just to deny US energy at refinery level. Extrapolate further and basically this well within reach of Central/South America countries past certain development threshold.

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by somenameforme on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:49AM (#50494386)
The impact of these strikes tends to be greatly exaggerated, both in terms of what was achieved as well as the ultimate effect. There's basic remedies available: increasing defenses at processing locations, decentralization of production, and so on. To this day, even Iran continues their production of drones and missiles.

Nukes by contrast can destroy entire cities with one bomb. Hiroshima alone killed more than 100,000 people and turned a developed city into a wasteland. [1] And that was with a 15kt weapon. The strongest weapon developed since then, Tsar Bomba, was 50,000kt. Now a days Hiroshima level nukes would be considered tiny tactical nukes for battlefield advantage. There's even been artillery shells developed with the same capability as Hiroshima. Modern strategic nukes, by contrast, can literally destroy countries.

MAD wasn't successful because of you take a lot of damage, but because you literally don't exist anymore. Like during the Proud Prophet war games [2], deaths were in the billions as the entire Northern Hemisphere was effectively extincted and rendered uninhabitable for decades. War starts with lots of young people paying the ultimate price - the idea that there's pain in victory is a given. MAD works because victory is literally impossible, regardless of how much pain you're willing to accept.

[1] - https://yandex.com/images/search?text=image%20of%20hiroshima...

[2] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proud_Prophet

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by dingaling on Saturday November 14, 2026 @12:12PM (#50498669)
> increasing defenses at processing locations

Defenses are finite. What are you going to sacrifice in order to improve your defences around processing plants?

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by rainworld on Saturday November 14, 2026 @02:24PM (#50499957)
> Defenses are finite.

So are attacks. They aren’t cheap either. Nor are the results of reciprocal attacks.

Result: https://www.euronews.com/2026/10/27/ukraines-70-billion-shor...

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by ethbr1 on Saturday November 14, 2026 @08:45PM (#50503165)
> There's basic remedies available: increasing defenses at processing locations, decentralization of production, and so on.

All of these have the net effect of decreasing production efficiency, relative to the global technological frontier.

Ergo, yes, there are viable methods to protecting against massed drone strikes.

But if you do it at country-scale your industry falls economically further and further behind the rest of the world.

Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by pseudohadamard on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:42AM (#50504884)
It's a bit different with refineries, where in theory all you need to get to the target is a lit match, and anything else, which doesn't amplify your payload by a factor of a million once the match is lit.
Re:Ukraine knocks out 36% of Russia's oil refining capacity ... by bean469 on Sunday November 15, 2026 @02:47PM (#50510021)
> Taiwan is just armed with so many cheap drones and rockets that for even a great power like China the guarantee of enormous economic damage at home is just not worth it.

Could be that China would anticipate this beforehand and have adequate air defenses on the ready