AI feels like a red herring as I've always considered the root of the problem to be cultural, ie. journalists adding story (ala New Journalism) because that gets attention but often results in sloppy arguments or subpar investigative work.
Additionally, I'd say this argument doesn't really address the point that chatbots, AI news farms, and rapid copycat books being generated by LLMs flooding the market cause confusion in every conceivable market.
I also believe that today’s journalists cut their teeth in the Buzzfeed era when industry incentives were to write as much clickbait as fast as possible.
Journalism is eroding its own credibility. Or, market incentives are. I don’t think journalists are cartoon villains, simply humans who have been put on a pedestal that is no longer earned.
Look, it is incredibly easy to say "all journalist are lying"
The problem is, normally that opinion is pushed by a specific group who will benefit from those journalists being discredited.
Now, with genai getting really rather good, there isn't really much between us and fully automatic bullshit as a service. Bad twitter, reddit & bluesky are very good examples of that. There are legions of people who are convinced that x is y, because someone spend some money to spread shit.
Sure, bad journalists need to be called out, as do bad networks (doesn't help that monopolies are fucking US journalism now)
but writing everyone off, without cause? thats just gonna let the grifters win.