It is. The annoyance comes from when the styling makes the message unclear as to which one is selected.
Re:A new UI annoyance
by micheljansen on Saturday January 12, 2013 @07:33AM
(#5047623)
Would be clearer if the active one looks "pressed", sort of like real radio buttons do.
Thanks. I'll have another play around with it and see what I can come up with.
In the screenshot, the Close button provides context - it's a clue saying "this is what a normal button looks like". But it's still not straight-forward enough: you have to think in order to understand that. Without that context, how would a user know whether the light button indicates "click me to switch", or whether it means "I'm active right now"?
A good UI doesn't make you think in order to to understand what an element does.
I think it's a fairly common UI pattern.