News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by halo on Friday January 11, 2013 @05:07PM (#5045350)
Strikes would not happen if US sports leagues were based around free market principles rather than monopolies that set artificial restrictions on athletes salaries and conditions.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by SeanLuke on Friday January 11, 2013 @05:56PM (#5045542)
Your approach is more or less what happens in world soccer. Clubs like PSG or Manchester United essentially purchase their championships. Libertarianism doesn't make for very interesting games or teams.

I think sports leagues could do with a little less privatization and a little more Green Bay.

Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by mattm on Friday January 11, 2013 @07:28PM (#5045877)
And yet the Premier League is one of the most successful leagues in the world...
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by forrestthewoods on Friday January 11, 2013 @09:01PM (#5046176)
Depending on one's definition of successful. Is the EPL the most popular league? Probably. Are the EPL teams the least profitable and most indebted? You bet they are! To the tune of 3.9 billion USD of debt across the league.

http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/news/premier-league-c...

Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by SeanLuke on Friday January 11, 2013 @09:41PM (#5046288)
Perhaps in much the same way that McDonalds is one of the most successful restaurants in the world.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by mrchapman on Friday January 11, 2013 @05:58PM (#5045548)
This is a lockout and not a strike, for one. Two 'free market principles rather than monopolies' - monopolies and free market principals are synonymous. They are not in opposition to one another (except in libertarian-land).
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by pkaler on Friday January 11, 2013 @05:38PM (#5045491)
At-will employment wouldn't make sense in professional sports. Imagine a team that got eliminated in the first round of the playoffs. A player could give two weeks notice and then join a team that was still competing.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by correctifier on Friday January 11, 2013 @05:54PM (#5045537)
Contracts would still exist, as well as a few other rules, but for the most part there wouldn't be things like a salary cap.

European club soccer is much closer to this model and it both creates really strong competition at the top end and a large spread between the top and bottom teams in a league. It is also very difficult to move from the bottom to the top without a huge amount of outside revenue.

Pro sports leagues in North America tend to operate as a monopoly, allowed because they have a union to balance it out. That's why both the NHL and NBA settled their lockouts right before the unions were able able to de-certify (NHL) or file an anti-trust (after decertifying in the NBA) lawsuit.

Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by rprasad on Friday January 11, 2013 @06:49PM (#5045725)
European club soccer is much closer to this model and it both creates really strong competition at the top end and a large spread between the top and bottom teams in a league. It is also very difficult to move from the bottom to the top without a huge amount of outside revenue.

No, it doesn't. The disparity in athlete talent and revenues between teams which make the Champions League and those which don't is greater than the disparity between say, the NFL and high school football. For the past decade, the winning teams of the Champions League and its feeder legs have all been one of the top 3 highest-spending teams in their respective leagues. There's simply no contest between, say, Manchester United and some random Irish club. In contrast, most of the professional American leagues reduce the talent disparity enough that either team could realistically win a match.

Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by correctifier on Friday January 11, 2013 @09:41PM (#5046287)
I may not have picked the best wording, but basically I'm agreeing that overall the disparity is very high. The upside is that games like Man City v Man U or Real Madrid v Barcelona end up being very entertaining.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by mikemac on Friday January 11, 2013 @05:46PM (#5045513)
The flip side of that is you would decimate small market teams who don't have the funds to compete with much larger markets. That means "buying" power for salaries would be centralized to a handful of teams, while the rest of the league would be less and less competitive until they would have to fold.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by NoPiece on Friday January 11, 2013 @05:55PM (#5045539)
Also, don't you think wages would be higher without unions? The collective bargaining is allowing professional sports owners to suppress all salaries. If there were no unions/collective bargaining, at the very least, the top players would immediately start to see much much bigger contracts. No sure if the journeyman player would benefit as much.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by sethist on Friday January 11, 2013 @06:24PM (#5045631)
Yes, wages for the best players would be higher, but wages for everyone else would be lower. The unions are designed to protect the majority of the players at the cost of the truly elite players.
Re:What the NHL Lockout Reveals About Capital and Labor by NoPiece on Saturday January 12, 2013 @01:18AM (#5046738)
I don't think that woud be true across the board - financially successful teams, like the New York Rangers, would likely pay more across the board in order to get better players.