News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ableton Live 13 by devrob on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @01:35PM (#50444301)
I was trying to build a version control system at one point. Basically an Ableton project is actually just a massive XML file that you could dump into a repo. I was trying to think of what a "git like" abstraction would work on top of it, but one of the challenges or problems I imagined would be all the VSTs/plugins and compatibility across units. In theory, the actual idea of freezing your XML and pushing to a git repo isn't so bad; it's similar to what Zepplin did with sketch ages ago, the fear was always - what happens when "figma" comes along and kills it but I didn't invest too much time into it.

The other challenge is media file management. Specifically, multiple MB & GB of media file storage means $$$ and git was magical because of free hosting. Then there was clip splicing and diffs - a wav file isn't exactly like a piece of code you can read directly and I don't have enough knowledge of the internals to make it work.

I was also worried Ableton would just take the idea and integrate it anyway and then it would be a wasted effort me

Re:Ableton Live 13 by devrob on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @02:04PM (#50444690)
I asked claude to 1 shot it and this is what it made: https://github.com/aquaflamingo/ableton-stem-vcs
Re:Ableton Live 13 by mtalantikite on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @02:33PM (#50445140)
Years ago there was a startup called Splice here in NYC where the original product was basically just that -- version control and collaboration for Ableton (and maybe other DAWs?). I remember having an interview at Union Square Ventures for a role there and a couple of the partners asked me about them as they were an investment, and I really couldn't see a viable business in it the same way GitHub was for git. I brought up the storage costs as well.

I just looked them up and it seems like they're still around and pivoted to a learning DAW and a plugin marketplace.

Re:Ableton Live 13 by cachvico on Tuesday November 10, 2026 @02:55PM (#50445456)
I was working on exactly the same idea - mobile app to record stems, cloud-based projects - and I remember the sinking feeling when I read the TechCrunch article covering Splice's launch.

Surprised that 10 years later on there's still no industry juggernaut owning collab music production.