Unless we intentionally replace them with less efficient automation, it’s a hard sell.
It’s really more of a physics problem than an automation problem.
There are no universal one setup suits all solutions here.
One advantage of large scale agrisolar projects (trialled since at least 2020) is better moisture retention through shade of increased condensation drip.
It's a balancing act - you appear to have a position hard up one end of a see saw.
FWiW I'm in a rural agricultural district with broad acre grains processed by large machinery, shaded acres of fruit trees and other varieties, solar farms, and more.
There's no issue here with having stock feed growing under solar panels, sheep and goats clean up there pretty well and we have many types of small vehicle, manned and unmanned, that can remote inspect, spray, sow, trim as necessary.
> Solar panels on cars are fascinating too, and the cost-benefit still isn’t there.
I'd disagree - solar panels on cars are not going to fully charge them by any means, here in Australia we have been running a long distance solar only "car" race for many years now and it's a game for uncomfortable transport of single humans in extremely lightweight streamlined custom one-offs (so far).
However, solar panels on cars are great for remote power and can serve to juice up an electric vehicle enough to get back to somewhere in the event of low charge, no stations, and need (less so in high population / reasonable density areas with good phone coverage)
Where I grew up, and what it seems like the article points to as a goal, a large farm is typically 100+ acres. They are very often of center-pivot design, and are harvested by combines pushing 15 feet tall (~4-5 meters). And typically require grain carts running alongside them. Nobody I know who owns and operates one of these farms would put panels over it and would ask "why not an empty plot somewhere else?"
And that question is my entire argument, in two parts:
One: The physics of an installation. On a pivot design, the panels have to sit high above everything on a structure that spans the field. And that's either a materials science problem - with spans that would need to be massive, or an engineering problem with spans that need to move with the irrigation system. Both are not easy. And even forgoing center-pivots, fields that are harvested by large equipment would need to install panels high enough up to easily clear equipment (at least 6 meters in my estimate).
Two: Cost. Cost scales with complexity, for installation, and maintenance. There are logistical costs of having dual-purpose land. You can't do PV installations or maintenance during planting and harvesting seasons. So if a row has technical issues at the wrong time, it needs to coordinate scheduling with the crop it is over. Dust maintenance would also be a major issue from the amount that is kicked up during harvest season. Completely ignoring the engineering cost and difficulty of a center-pivot field, a raised installation is much more expensive and technically demanding than a ground-based one. All of the PVs need to be raised by some sort of crane and placed, and crew need to use boom trucks to fasten and connect the panels and cables.
To reiterate my original point, unless land is a constraint, I don't see a strong case for stacking solar over crops. Fruit crops might be a better use case in your region specifically, and an argument could be made, but with the numbers the article was suggesting, that would make up a very small percentage of overall crops required to make numbers work.
On solar in cars, I think we are in agreement. I believe roof solar on a house that charges an electric car beats solar on the car for just about everyone, and only in some rare situations, like a cross-desert competition, or for those who really want to be able to drive completely on solar for long distances, does it make sense. Which is analogous to my point about agri-solar installations.
Something I've always absent-mindedly wondered about when agrivoltaics comes up is integrating a gantry/rail system of sorts for the farm equipment. It's definitely infeasible for many reasons, but it's fun to think about. Instead of equipment pulled by tractors, have the equipment ride above the field on rails, held up by the same poles the solar panels are on.
The article’s biggest claim is that devoting one percent of US farmland to agrivoltaics could cover 20 percent of the country’s electricity, pointing at the Texas to Nebraska to California corridor, which is exactly where big mechanized farms are most common.
They run large equipment (combines, sprayer booms, center pivot irrigation systems[1], etc). To keep that working under panels you need tall posts, wide spans, and a layout that matches the equipment paths, which would push structural cost significantly above a ground installation. All maintenance would require a boom truck, not just a ground crew. And center pivots in particular (very common) need an entire circle cleared for the system to pivot, meaning a multi-acre span with no posts for the pivot to hit, which is simply infeasible.
That’s before accounting for pesticide spray and dust on the PVs, or the logistical burden of running PV crews through a working farm.
It’s also worth noting that the study itself was broccoli, which is hand harvested and about the best case crop for this. Even so, the broccoli took 25 extra days to mature. On a farm running multiple rotations a season that lost time has a real cost, separate from the structural costs.
This innovation has a lot more promise on smaller plots. Co-ops, market gardens, specialty crops, and the like that don’t rely on large equipment. I’d be surprised to ever see it on a large farm.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Center-pivot_irrigation