That's a good rule. It means SE can focus on that thing. But it's a great shame that the huge knowledge of the SE sites is locked in that format.
There's quite a lot of heat generated around the fuzzy borders of acceptable and unacceptable borders, and having a question closed or deleted doesn't feel good.
Meta is death. I kind of agree, yet SE does have active meta. SE also has chat stuff.
So, would it really kill them to have "freeform SE question site"? It could be a paid feature (although recommending people buy a sub to post a question would cause all kinds of furore).
Thus, you'd have:
http://gamedev.stackexchange.com/
http://meta.gamedev.stackexchange.com/
*http://freeform.gamedev.stackexchange.com/
It would still have strict rules, and mods, and etc. But it would allow more open form discussion. They might need to have a different structure to allow threading and better replies?
Because of this, http://programmers.stackexchange.com exists, which is a site that allows more free-form questions.