News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by beloch on Thursday November 05, 2026 @09:14PM (#50387291)
Here's why I'm skeptical:

It may only be a short-term circumstance that you need a data centre to run AI for lucrative applications. Thirty years ago you needed a mainframe to beat Kaspersky at chess. Algorithm's got better, and now you can beat the mainframe that beat Kaspersky with a bot running on a desktop Pentium of the day[1]. You could still, today, devote a full hyperscale data centre to create a chess bot to beat all other chess bots, but nobody is doing that because there's no money in it.

The frontier is continually pushed outwards. At it's outer edge you need mainframes and data-centres. Once it pushes past, you don't. There wasn't a lot of money in Chess or protein folding, despite the later having huge potential for public benefit. There is a lot of money in coding and middle management, and that's what currently has tech-bros in a frenzy. However, there's no guarantee that what the frontier moves onto next will be lucrative. It might be more chess and protein folding. If, as Algorithm's and hardware improve, coding moves to local models (Sam Altman's nightmare) and nothing lucrative immediately replaces that, what are these companies going do do with their massive data-centres?

The scale of investment we're seeing these companies commit only makes sense if they have multiple decades to reap the returns. They may well not have that much time.

_____________________

[1]https://hackaday.com/2026/11/05/pitting-a-modern-chess-engin...

Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by ratscylla on Thursday November 05, 2026 @09:17PM (#50387313)
Kasparov, btw
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by dofm on Thursday November 05, 2026 @11:58PM (#50388404)
No this is Ned Kaspersky, from Moscow (Idaho)
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by selimthegrim on Friday November 06, 2026 @02:51PM (#50397467)
This must be 3HN1
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by dofm on Friday November 06, 2026 @05:32PM (#50399390)
No don't worry. It's just allergies.
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by selimthegrim on Saturday November 07, 2026 @09:02AM (#50404612)
3CP1, comrade
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by senordevnyc on Thursday November 05, 2026 @09:20PM (#50387330)
Chess is a fixed target, so as a benchmark, it can be saturated.

Reality can’t be saturated. The set of things you can accomplish with more intelligence is unbounded. So while cheap models will continue to proliferate, there will always be a massive market at the frontier, and that won’t ever change.

Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by postalrat on Thursday November 05, 2026 @09:45PM (#50387513)
Intelligence is bounded by it's interface to reality. Until that problem is solved the set of what AI can accomplish in a reasonable timeframe is quite limited.
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by senordevnyc on Friday November 06, 2026 @06:57AM (#50391312)
Until that problem is solved

Guess what could help solve it? :)

Seriously though, this “problem” will never be fully solved, we’ll just get better and better at connecting AI to the broader world, and to me that’s already the story of the last few years. Models get better, they’re able to build and drive tools to interact with both the digital and physical world better, which helps build the next generation of models, and so on.

Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by fatcatsbestcats on Thursday November 05, 2026 @10:30PM (#50387817)
Conversely, the TAM for tasks that cheap models can and have been able to one-shot for a while now is orders of magnitude larger than the TAM at the frontier. While it’s kind of cool that frontier models are able to solve Millennium Prize problems, there just isn’t a huge market for that sort of thing. Otherwise, professional mathematicians would be getting paid a lot more than they do now, and there would be more of them.
Re:Major Investors Are Skeptical Anthropic IPO Can Achieve $... by elcritch on Thursday November 05, 2026 @11:17PM (#50388123)
Nah there's plenty of TAM for frontier models even if just to take over market share from cheaper models. Fields like law or medical cn always use lower hallucination rates and smarter "human social" intelligence.