Re:Insects Don't Swarm at LED Lights
by pasquinelli on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @05:54PM
(#50372602)
a conclusion can be right even if an argument for it is wrong.
If P then Q, P therefore Q. Q is not the conclusion, it's just the consequent. If P is false, then Q could be true, but claiming Q is true because P is true when P is actually false is a wrong conclusion.
Re:Insects Don't Swarm at LED Lights
by pasquinelli on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:33PM
(#50375220)
i don't see what point your making.
take something you know to be true. now come up with a stupid, falacious argument for it. now you can see that seeing an argument is bad doesn't mean the conclusion is wrong.
Even if the fact is true, if the argument is false then the conclusion is false. The conclusion is not just the fact bit at the end of an argument. The conclusion is the summarized reasoning/argument for the fact.
Re:Insects Don't Swarm at LED Lights
by dylan604 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @06:21PM
(#50372822)
> Sky is always brighter than the land, moon is not required.
Speaking of things being wrong...how can you come to this conclusion? There are many beaches where turtle hatchlings get confused by all of the lights on land where they crawl away from the ocean instead of towards it. Land is so bright, that the vast majority of humans can no longer see the night sky. So again I ask, how do you come to the conclusion that land is darker than the sky?
I think the missing part is "in the absence of artificial light".
In "the absence of artificial light", please explain how land will be brighter than the sky
Sky is always brighter than the land, moon is not required.
Lamp movement is the confusion of where is “up”
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-44785-3