News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The lost malloc() by 1718627440 on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @09:25AM (#50365960)
You already need a virtual destructor here anyway, because it needs to know about the actual type B, which includes it's size.
Re:The lost malloc() by dragontamer on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:09AM (#50367620)
[delayed]
Re:The lost malloc() by adev_ on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:36AM (#50368075)
> What is the size of A? Answer: you never know in C++ due to polymorphism. It might be a B or other subclass. It is truly a variable length operation.

You could easily go around it.

In your example, to have correct C++, you need to have declared a virtual destruct-or for B. You could encode the size of B in a static offset from the virtual destructor or simply as a return value from it.

This is not how it is done now, mainly because how free was designed in C.

free() design is a terrible mistake. Probably one of the worst design mistake of C with the null terminated / no-length specified string and the preprocessor.

The compiler knows when creating destructor what is the size of B. You easily can there inject

Re:The lost malloc() by dgrunwald on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @11:50AM (#50368285)
But it's possible for `delete tmp;` to call a user-defined `operator delete()` in the derived class! https://godbolt.org/z/hvePa6jMP

The way this works under the hood is that every polymorphic class has two destructors (so two destructor entries in the vtable): the "complete object destructor" is the ~A() you know from C++, and then there's also the "deleting destructor" which combines ~A() + delete.

So the deleting destructor can call free() while knowing the derived object size, even for a delete-via-base-class-pointer.

Re:The lost malloc() by cowlevel on Wednesday November 04, 2026 @08:44PM (#50374010)
At least in the MSVC implementation, "delete tmp;" calls "operator delete" polymorphically, through a hidden virtual function. I think this is because derived classes may override "operator delete"?